INTRODUCTION
Porphyromonas species belonging to the phylum
Bacteroidetes are nonmotile, Gram-negative, rod-shaped, anaerobic bacteria that are considered emerging pathogens in humans and animals (
1,
2). In general,
Porphyromonas species, and in particular
Porphyromonas gingivalis, the best-studied representative of the genus, are known as oral pathogens causing gingivitis, periodontitis, endodontic diseases, and apical abscesses in human and animals (
3–5). However, several
Porphyromonas species are involved in other human and animal pathologies, such as metritis, peritonitis, interdigital necrobacillosis, and necrotic vulvovaginitis (
2,
6–8). Given that phenotypic identification and discrimination of
Porphyromonas and
Prevotella species had been inconsistent (
9), genotypic species identification based on 16S rRNA gene sequences was developed and was used successfully thereafter (
10).
Porphyromonas somerae and
Porphyromonas levii, two closely related species, are regarded as pathogenic species of humans and cattle, respectively. Clinical manifestations of
P. somerae (a
P. levii-like species) include soft tissue and bone infections, brain abscesses, and otitis media with mastoiditis (
6,
7,
11). In ruminants,
P. levii has been isolated from cows with necrobacillosis (
8), papillomatous digital dermatitis (
12), and acute interdigital phlegmon (
13) and from cows during an outbreak of bovine necrotic vulvovaginitis (
6). However,
P. levii was also reported as an opportunistic pathogen in the rumen of cattle (
2,
14) and was found in healthy cattle herds (
15).
Herein, we report data on the bacteriological isolation and genotypic identification of, and the clinical signs, laboratory results, and pathology that are indicative of an outbreak of pyogranulomatous pneumonia associated with acute respiratory disease in goats (Capra aegagrus hircus) caused by, a yet-unknown Porphyromonas species, which we tentatively named “Porphyromonas katsikii.”
RESULTS
An outbreak of acute respiratory disease affecting 6 out of 25 goats occurred in a small farm in northwest Greece. The animals that were presented to a private veterinarian showed loss of appetite for 3 days. The clinical examination revealed high fever (41.5°C), lethargy, an empty-appearing abdomen, hyperactive rumen motility, purulent nasal discharge, open-mouth breathing, and tachypnea. On auscultation, wheezing sounds were detected. A biochemical blood analysis of a characteristic diseased animal, a 2-year-old female goat, indicated that globulin (2.9 g/dl [reference range, 2.7 to 4.1 g/dl]), creatinine (1.4 mg/dl [reference range, 1.0 to 1.8 mg/dl]), glucose (68 mg/dl [reference range, 50 to 75 mg/dl]), and total bilirubin (1.1 mg/dl [reference range, 0.1 to 1.7 mg/dl]) concentrations were within their respective reference ranges. In addition, hepatic enzyme activities (sorbitol dehydrogenase, 17 IU/liter [reference range, 14 to 23.6 IU/liter]; gamma-glutamyl transferase, 26 IU/liter [reference range, 20 to 56 IU/liter]) were also within their respective reference ranges. A dipstick screening for proteinuria, hematuria, and ketone bodies in the urine was negative. Additionally, microscopic examination of Giemsa-stained thin- and thick-blood films did not reveal the presence of any blood parasites (Anaplasma ovis, Babesia ovis, or Babesia motasi). The animals were treated intramuscularly with 20 mg/kg of body weight of tylosin (Tylan 50; Elanco, Greensfield, IN, USA) twice per day. However, no clinical improvement was achieved, and all 6 affected animals died on the 1st to 3rd day of therapy. The remaining animals showed no symptoms. There were no risk factors, such as stress, crowding, or viral infections, recorded for the herd prior to the outbreak.
In the affected animals, gross lesions were confined to the lungs and consisted of generalized interstitial edema with multiple light-tan to light-yellow branching and anastomosing tracts. The edema moderately elevated the surface of the whole lung parenchyma. These pathologies were consistent with severely ectatic airways frequently distended to form a prominent nodular collection of exudate ranging from 1 mm to 4 cm in diameter. Morphologically, these lesions were consistent with a subacute, severe, and multifocal to coalescing bronchopneumonia with severe bronchiectasis, presumably of an infectious origin (
Fig. 1). Furthermore, microscopic examination of the histologic section of the lung of the affected 2-year-old female goat confirmed the macroscopic morphological diagnosis by revealing multifocal to coalescing severe active suppurate bronchopneumonia characterized by bronchial and bronchiolar lumen filled with amorphous basophilic mucoid material admixed with viable and degenerating neutrophils, sloughed degenerated epithelial cells, macrophages, and cellular debris. Furthermore, the alveolar walls were multifocally expanded by infiltrating lymphocytes, macrophages, plasma cells, and neutrophils. Additionally, there was moderate hyperplasia of the bronchus-associated lymphoid tissue (BALT) with mild to moderate multifocal hyperplasia of the smooth muscles of the airways, diffuse edema, and thickening of the pleura. May-Grünwald Giemsa-stained lung tissue revealed the presence of 5-μm-long rods, indicating the presence of bacteria in the affected lung foci.
Microbiological examination of lung samples taken from multiple ectatic airway lumina revealed no growth under any of the conditions tested after 96 h. However, after 10 to 14 days under anaerobic conditions, growth of small black-pigmented colonies of rod-shaped Gram-negative bacteria were found on the blood agar medium from samples of 3 affected animals. These bacteria also grew on the blood agar medium supplemented with kanamycin or ampicillin but not with vancomycin. DNA amplification from the black-pigmented colonies and subsequent sequence analysis of the amplified
rrs 16S rRNA gene showed the same 1,408-bp sequence for isolates of all 3 samples (GenBank accession number KM360064). A comparison of this DNA sequence by BLAST revealed 92% sequence similarity (identical nucleotides) with the
rrs genes of
Porphyromonas levii (GenBank accession number L16493) and
Porphyromonas somerae (GenBank accession number L16493) as the closest known bacterial species.
P. levii and
P. somerae are pathogenic
Porphyromonas species of cattle and humans, respectively. The interspecies variability of the 16S rRNA gene sequence of this yet-undescribed
Porphyromonas sp. from goats compared to that of the 16S rRNA gene sequence of
P. levii or
P. somerae is 8%. This is largely above the 3% difference that is generally recommended to distinguish a new species (
22). We therefore conclude that the
Porphyromonas strains isolated from the diseased goats represent a novel species that we tentatively named
Porphyromonas katsikii (κατσικα [katsika], Greek for goat).
Figure 2 shows the phylogenetic position of
Porphyromonas katsikii in relation to the closest relatives of
Porphyromonas and selected species of
Bacteroides and
Prevotella.
In order to determine whether Porphyromonas katsikii was present as the major bacterial species in the lungs of all the diseased animals, total DNA extracted from lung tissues of the affected animals was analyzed by PCR with the universal 16S rRNA gene primers 16SUNI-L and 16SUNI-R and by sequencing of the PCR-amplified fragments. Sequence analysis of the PCR fragments we obtained resulted in the same sequence as that found for the strains (GenBank accession number KM360064). As no double or multiple peaks were found in the chromatograms of Sanger sequencing of the rrs gene amplicons from the lung samples, we concluded that Porphyromonas katsikii was the predominant or sole bacterial species found in the lungs of the diseased animals.
Direct PCR analysis of lung tissues using specific primers designed for the amplification of a specific part of the rrs gene of Porphyromonas katsikii revealed a strong positive PCR signal of 800 bp for all lung samples of the diseased animals. Lung tissue samples from 6 healthy goats taken from slaughter were used as negative controls, and samples from 7 goats with pasteurellosis pneumonia caused by Mannheimia haemolytica were used as specificity controls. The controls showed no signal upon PCR amplification with the specific Porphyromonas katsikii primers. Furthermore, subgingival samples taken from the 6 healthy goats and fecal samples from healthy goats, where Porphyromonas species are expected, showed no amplicons when tested with the P. katsikii-specific PCR, in contrast to PCR with the universal 16S rRNA primers, which was positive in these samples.
DISCUSSION
To our knowledge, this is the first report of a
Porphyromonas lung infection in goats. As bacteriological diagnostics using culture methods often result in overgrowth by secondary and much faster-growing bacteria resulting from contaminations of the dead carcasses, the impact of
Porphyromonas species in specimens of diseased animals is not easy to pinpoint, and the primary pathogen quite often remains undetected due to its slow growth properties. In the current case,
Porphyromonas grew only after 10 days or more and was identified in only 3 animals. However, we were able to detect
Porphyromonas katsikii in the lung samples of all affected animals by PCR with universal 16S rRNA gene primers followed by DNA sequencing, where it was revealed to be the only species recognized. It has to be noted that universal bacterial 16S rRNA gene primers used for PCR resulted uniquely in detectable 16S rRNA gene fragments corresponding to
Porphyromonas katsikii, hence indicating that other bacteria were comparatively at very low abundance or absent in the affected lung tissue. Furthermore,
P. katsikii was also detected in the affected lung tissues by the specific PCR primers. In contrast, tissues from the lungs of healthy goats or from goats with other pneumonic infections were devoid of the specific PCR signal. Hence, we postulate that the new
Porphyromonas species, tentatively named
Porphyromonas katsikii, was the causative agent of lung disease in the goats affected in this outbreak. The closest relatives to
P. katsikii are
P. levii and
P. somerae, which cause various infections in animals and humans, respectively, such as vulvovaginitis, chronic skin and soft tissue infections, and bone infections (
6,
7,
15).
Local infections due to
Porphyromonas species are generally caused by bacterial strains present in tissues prior to the development of the clinical infection (
1). In a previous study (
6), cases of necrotic vulvovaginitis were associated with
P. levii in cows. In that study, lesions of the genital tract and immunosuppressive stressors, such as calving, age, and primiparity of the cows, were considered risk factors of that outbreak. In our current report, the primary site of infection was not determined.
P. katsikii was not detected by specific PCR from the gingival pockets of healthy goats, where the habitat of
Porphyromonas species is expected, or from the feces of healthy goats. Furthermore, there was no evidence of immune suppression in the goat. It could be speculated that lungworm, which is very common among goats, especially in goats reared in backyard farms, could be the primary site of infection prior to dissemination of the bacterium to the lung. However, no ova or larvae of nematodes were evidenced in the affected animals.
Porphyromonas katsikii is an anaerobic bacterium, although slight growth of this bacterium in a 5% CO
2 atmosphere on mycoplasma medium was observed. Hence, one can speculate that airways filled with exudate might have served as anaerobic conditions in order to initiate the infection. The absence of
P. katsikii in healthy goats, as revealed by analyzing subgingival samples, where
Porphyromonas species most likely are expected to have their ecological niche, and feces suggests that the infectious agent may not be a commensal organism in these animals.
Porphyromonas infections are most probably underdiagnosed in veterinary and also human medicine, because appropriate media and growth conditions and particularly long incubation times of up to 2 weeks are not implemented in the procedures of routine diagnostic laboratories. However, in the case of a disease outbreak with an undetermined etiology, we suggest implementation of procedures with extended incubation times and the use of various growth conditions in order to isolate and identify rare bacterial pathogens, such as Porphyromonas species and other slow-growing Bacteroidetes, as potential infectious agents. Furthermore, the amplification of 16S rRNA genes using universal primes and subsequent DNA sequence analysis was shown to be a valuable rapid diagnostic tool. The current report indicates that the newly identified species Porphyromonas katsikii should be considered a possible etiological agent of lung infections in goats and related animal species.