Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus as an Agent of Emerging and Reemerging Infection
Abstract
SUMMARY
INTRODUCTION
TAXONOMY AND VIROLOGY OF SARS-CoV
VIRAL LIFE CYCLE
SEQUENCE OF THE SARS EPIDEMIC AND MOLECULAR EVOLUTION OF THE VIRUS
Sequence of Events
Molecular Evolution
EPIDEMIOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS
CLINICAL FEATURES
HISTOPATHOLOGICAL CHANGES OF SARS
Histological Changes
Immunological Profiles
PATHOGENESIS, IMMUNE RESPONSE, AND HOST SUSCEPTIBILITY
Interaction between Viral and Cellular Factors
Adaptive Immune Response
Host Susceptibility
LABORATORY DIAGNOSIS OF SARS-CoV INFECTION
Nucleic Acid Amplification Assays
Antigen Detection Assays
Antibody Detection Assays
CLINICAL MANAGEMENT AND ANTIVIRALS
INFECTION CONTROL AND LABORATORY SAFETY
PASSIVE IMMUNIZATION AND DEVELOPMENT OF A SARS-CoV VACCINE
Use of Convalescent-Phase Serum and Neutralizing Antibody
Active Immunization
ANIMAL MODELS AND ANIMALS SUSCEPTIBLE TO SARS-CoV
SHOULD WE BE READY FOR THE REEMERGENCE OF SARS?


| Gene nomenclature (no. of amino acid residues in product) | Gene product and/or characteristic(s) (reference[s]) | Effect on cellular response of host (reference[s]) |
|---|---|---|
| Orf1a/b | ||
| nsp1 (180) | Expression promoted degradation of host endogenous mRNAs, which may inhibit host protein synthesis and prevented endogenous IFN-β mRNA accumulation (167) | Induce CCL5, CXCL10 (IP10), and CCL3 expression in human lung epithelial cells via activation of NF-κB; increases cellular RNA degradation, which might facilitate SARS-CoV replication or block immune responses (81, 192) |
| nsp2 (638) | Deletion attenuates viral growth and RNA synthesis (106) | |
| nsp3 (1,922) | Papain-like protease 2; proteolytic processing of the viral polyprotein at 3 sites and participation in synthesis of subgenomic RNA segment (15, 121, 224) | Putative catalytic triad (Cys1651-His1812-Asp1826) and zinc-binding site have deubiquitinating activity; this unexpected activity in addition to its papain-like protease suggests a novel viral strategy to modulate the host cell ubiquitination machinery to its advantage (15, 224, 279) |
| ADP-ribose 1-phosphatase; dephosphorylates Appr-1‴-p, a side product of cellular tRNA splicing, to ADP-ribose (271) | ||
| nsp4 (500) | Not known | |
| nsp5 (306) | 3C-like protease; proteolytic processing of the replicative polyprotein at 11 specific sites and forming key functional enzymes such as replicase and helicase (5, 394) | Growth arrest and apoptosis via caspase-3 and caspase-9 activities demonstrated in SARS-CoV 3CLpro-expressing human promonocyte cells with increased activation of the nuclear factor-κB-dependent reporter (222) |
| nsp6 (290) | Not known | |
| nsp7 (83) | Three-dimensional structure by nuclear magnetic resonance study found potential sites for protein-protein interactions (261) | |
| nsp8 (198) | Putative RNA-dependent RNA polymerase; crystal structure of the hexadecameric nsp7-nsp8 possesses a central channel with dimensions and positive electrostatic properties favorable for nucleic acid binding; it is probably another unique RNA-dependent RNA polymerase for its large genome (158, 414) | |
| nsp9 (113) | Three-dimensional crystal structure of a dimer which binds viral RNA and interacts with nsp8 (92, 316) | |
| nsp10 (139) | Crystal structure suggests a nucleic acid binding function within a larger RNA binding protein complex for viral gene transcription and replication (166, 309) | Interacts specifically with the NADH 4L subunit and cytochrome oxidase II with depolarization of inner mitochondrial membrane of transfected human embryo lung fibroblast and extensive cytopathic effect (210) |
| nsp11 (13) | Not known | |
| nsp12 (932) | RNA-dependent RNA polymerase; replication and transcription to produce genome- and subgenome-sized RNAs of both polarities (158) | |
| nsp13 (601) | Helicase (dNTPase and RNA 5′-triphosphatase activities) (95) | |
| nsp14 (527) | 3′→5′-exoribonuclease; this unusual 3′→5′-exoribonuclease activity supplements the endoribonuclease activity in the replication of the giant RNA genome (242) | |
| nsp15 (346) | Uridylate-specific endoribonuclease; RNA endonuclease that is critically involved in the coronavirus replication cycle (284) | |
| nsp16 (298) | Putative 2′-O-ribose methyltransferase (343) | |
| Orf2 (1,255) | Spike protein; binds to the host cell receptor ACE2 and other coreceptors, mediates viral entry into host cells as a type 1 viral fusion protein; required acidification of endosomes for efficient S-mediated viral entry; proteolytic cleavage by abundantly expressed infected cell membrane-associated factor Xa into S1 and S2; protease activation required for cell-cell fusion (159, 162, 206, 214, 227, 301, 334) | 293 T cells transfected with ACE2 can form multinucleated syncytia with cells expressing the spike; intraperitoneal injections of spike protein into mice reduced ACE2 expression in lungs and worsened acute lung failure in vivo that can be attenuated by blocking the renin-angiotensin pathway (181); recombinant baculovirus expressing different deletion and insertion fragments identified the functional region of S protein from amino acids 324-688, which can induce the release of IL-8 in lung cells (43); induces unfolded protein response in cultured cells as SARS-CoV with a substantial amt of S protein accumulation in the endoplasmic reticulum, which may modulate viral replication (30) |
| Orf3a (274) | Forms potassium-sensitive ion channel, may promote virus budding and release (234) | Overexpression in cell line may trigger apoptosis; its expression in A549 lung epithelial cells up-regulates mRNA and intracellular and secreted levels of all three subunits, alpha, beta, and gamma, of fibrinogen, which is also observed in SARS-CoV-infected Vero E6 cells; it is highly immunogenic and induces neutralizing antibodies (193, 321); 3a/X1 and 7a/X4 were capable of activating NF-κB and c-Jun N-terminal kinase and significantly enhanced IL-8 promoter activity in A549 cells; enhanced production of inflammatory chemokines that were known to be up-regulated in SARS-CoV infection (169) |
| Orf3b (154) | Predominately localized to the nucleolus in different transfected cells (409) | Vero E6 but not 293T cells transfected with a construct for expressing Orf3b underwent necrosis as early as 6 h after transfection but underwent simultaneous necrosis and apoptosis at later time points; Orf3b inhibits expression of IFN-β at synthesis and signaling (175, 178) |
| Orf4 (76) | Envelope protein; synthetic peptides form ion channels in planar lipid bilayers, which are more permeable to monovalent cations than to monovalent anions; putatively involved in viral budding and release (359) | Induced apoptosis in transfected Jurkat T cells especially in the absence of growth factors; a novel BH3-like region was located in the C-terminal cytosolic domain of SARS-CoV E protein can bind to Bcl-xL, whose overexpression can antagonize apoptosis; this may explain the consistent lymphopenia found in SARS patients (397) |
| Orf5 (221) | Membrane protein; surface protein responsible for viral assembly and budding | M protein induced apoptosis in HEK293T cells, which could be suppressed by caspase inhibitors (29) |
| Orf6 (63) | Novel membrane protein that accelerates replication and virulence of a recombinant mouse coronavirus expressing Orf6; an important virulence factor in vivo demonstrated in a mouse model (327) | Inhibits both IFN synthesis and signaling; inhibited nuclear translocation but not phosphorylation of STAT1 (178); Orf6 is localized to the endoplasmic reticulum/Golgi membrane of infected cells; it binds and disrupts nuclear import complex formation by tethering karyopherin alpha 2 and karyopherin beta 1 to the membrane; this retention of the complex at the endoplasmic reticulum/Golgi membrane leads to a loss of STAT1 transport into the nucleus despite viral RNA-induced IFN signaling; thus, it blocks the expression of STAT1-activated genes, which are essential for establishing an antiviral state (100) |
| Orf7a (122) | Unique type I transmembrane protein; involved in viral assembly by interacting with M and E, which are essential for virus-like particle formation when coexpressed with S and N (97, 150, 245) | Expression of Orf7a induces apoptosis via a caspase-3-dependent pathway and in cell lines derived from different organs including lung, kidney, and liver (179, 320, 408) |
| Orf7b (44) | Not known | |
| Orf8a (39) | Not known | Orf8a was localized in mitochondria, and overexpression resulted in increases in mitochondrial transmembrane potential, reactive oxygen species production, caspase-3 activity, and cellular apoptosis; Orf8a enhances viral replication and induces apoptosis through a mitochondrion-dependent pathway (49) |
| Orf8b (84) | May modulate viral replication; expression of E was down-regulated by Orf8b but not Orf8a or Orf8ab (172) | |
| Orf9 (422) | Nucleocapsid protein; binding and packaging of viral RNA in assembly of the virion (147) | N antagonized IFN by inhibiting synthesis of IFN-β (130); NF-κB activation in Vero E6 cells expressing the N protein is dose dependent (220); N may cause inflammation of the lungs by activating COX-2 gene expression by binding directly to the promoter, resulting in inflammation through multiple COX-2 signaling cascades (393); induced apoptosis of COS-1 monkey kidney but not 293T cells in the absence of growth factors; induced actin reorganization in cells devoid of growth factors (315) |
| Orf9b (98) | Crystal structure of Orf9b, an alternative ORF within the N gene, may be involved in membrane attachment and associates with intracellular vesicles, consistent with a role in assembly of the virion (241) |
| Phase and date | Important event, phase of evolution, and genotypic marker(s)b |
|---|---|
| Early | Most isolates had SNV genotypic marker of the GZ02 reference nucleotide at positions 17564, 21721, 22222, 23823, and 27827 of G:A:C:G:C; some initial cases had the 29-bp insertion or 82-bp deletion at Orf8; avg Ka/Ks ratio of >1, which was higher than that of the middle phase, which indicates strong positive selection |
| 16 November 2002 | First case that fulfilled the WHO definition of SARS at Foshan, Guangdong Province, China |
| 17 December 2002 | Chef from Heyuan who worked at a restaurant in Shenzhen had atypical pneumonia |
| 26 December 2002 to 20 January 2003 | Outbreak of similar cases at Zhongshan |
| Middle | SNV genotypic marker of G:A:C:T:C; avg Ka/Ks ratio was higher than that of the late phase but was <1, which indicates purifying selection |
| 12 January 2003 | Outbreak in Guangzhou resulted in complicated SARS cases transferred to the major hospitals in Guangzhou |
| 31 January 2003 | Outbreak in Guanzhou hospitals involving patients and health care workers |
| Late | SNV marker of T:G:T:T:T; avg Ka/Ks ratio shows stabilization of nonsynonymous mutation rate; some isolates had 415-bp deletion at Orf8 |
| 21 February 2003 | 65-yr-old doctor from Guangdong Province resided at “hotel M” in Hong Kong (index patient); unwell since 15 February and admitted to the hospital on 22 February; infected 17 residents at hotel M, some of whom traveled to Vietnam, Singapore, and Toronto, where they started new local clusters of cases |
| 26 February 2003 | Hotel M contact was admitted to a hospital in Hanoi and started a nosocomial outbreak |
| 4 March 2003 | Another hotel M contact was admitted to Prince of Wales Hospital in Hong Kong and started a nosocomial outbreak |
| 5 March 2003 | Another hotel M contact died in Toronto; five family members were affected |
| 12 March 2003 | WHO issued a global alert |
| 14 March 2003 | Clusters of atypical pneumonia were reported in Singapore and Toronto, which were epidemiologically linked to hotel M outbreak |
| 15 March 2003 | WHO named this new disease SARS after receiving reports of more than 150 cases; WHO issued emergency travel advice in response to SARS |
| 21 March 2003 | A novel coronavirus was identified in two patients with SARS in Hong Kong; the agent, isolated in rhesus monkey kidney cells (fRhk4), produced a cytopathic effect; in an immunofluorescence antibody assay, sera from SARS patients had rising antibody titers against the virus-infected cells |
| 22 to 27 March 2003 | Isolation of a novel coronavirus was confirmed in laboratories of the United States and Germany |
| 12 April 2003 | Sequencing of the full genome of SARS-CoV was completed |
| 16 April 2003 | WHO announces that SARS-CoV is the causative agent of SARS |
| June 2003 | A virus with 99.8% nucleotide identity with SARS-CoV was isolated from palm civets and other game food mammals |
| 5 July 2003 | Absence of further transmission in Taiwan signaled the end of human-to-human transmission |
| Aftermath | |
| 3 September 2003 | Laboratory-acquired SARS-CoV infection was reported in Singapore |
| 16 December 2003 to 8 January 2004 | 4 symptomatic cases and 1 asymptomatic case of SARS due to animal-to-human transmission occurred in the city of Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, China; all isolates had a 29-bp signature sequence insertion for animal SARS-CoV in Orf8 |
| 17 December 2003 | Second laboratory-acquired SARS-CoV infection reported in Taiwan |
| 25 March and 17 April 2004 | Third and fourth laboratory-acquired SARS-CoV infection reported in Beijing, China |
| 16 September 2005 | Finding of SARS-CoV-like virus in horseshoe bats; all isolates sequenced had a 29-bp signature sequence for bat SARS-CoV |
| Clinical and laboratory features (% positive isolates [no. of isolates studied/total no.]) (reference)a | Viral load for indicated day(s) after onset of symptoms (reference) | Blood immune profile or histopathological feature (reference) |
|---|---|---|
| Systemic involvement | Mean 1.1 log copies/ml between days 10 and 15 in serum (156) | Increased mean serum concentrations of IL-16, TNF-α, and transforming growth factor β1 but decreased IL-18 between days 3 and 27 (16); increased IFN-γ and inflammatory cytokines IL-1, IL-6, and IL-12 for at least 2 wk; chemokine profile demonstrated increased neutrophil chemokine IL-8, MCP-1, and Th1 chemokine IP-10 (360); increased serum concn of IP10, MIG, and IL-8 during the first wk was associated with adverse outcome or death (325) |
| Fever (99.9 [751/752]) | ||
| Chill or rigors (51.5 [377/732]) | ||
| Malaise (58.8 [317/539]) | ||
| Respiratory involvement | Mean 2.4 log copies/ml between days 10 and 15 for NPA (156), 9.58 × 102-5.93 × 106 copies/ml for throat swab and 7.08 × 102-6.38 × 108 copies/ml for saliva between days 2 and 9 (349), and 2 × 104-1 × 1010 copies/ml between days 5 and 51 for lung tissue (96) | IP10 highly expressed in both lung and lymphoid tissues, with monocyte-macrophage infiltration and depletion of lymphocytes (163); increased alveolar macrophages and CD8 cells, decreased CD4-to-CD8 ratio, and increased TNF-α, IL-6, IL-8, RANTES, and MCP-1 levels in bronchoalveolar lavage samples (124, 344); IP10 was increased in lung tissue from patients who died of SARS (325); increased differential expression of cytokines within these pulmonary tissues, including Stat1, IFN-regulatory factor 1, IL-6, IL-8, and IL-18, often characteristic of patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (8) |
| Rhinorrhea (13.8 [50/362]) | ||
| Sore throat (16.5 [91/552]) | ||
| Cough (65.5 [460/702]) | ||
| Dyspnea (45.9 [282/614]) | ||
| Cardiovascular involvement | 1 × 104-2.8 × 107 copies/ml between days 5 and 23 for cardiac tissue (96) | Subclinical diastolic impairment without systolic involvement but no interstitial lymphocytic infiltrate or myocyte necrosis in histology (211); gross pulmonary thromboemboli and marantic cardiac valvular vegetations in some autopsies (67) |
| Tachycardia (46.1 [71/154]) | ||
| Bradycardia (14.9 [18/121]) (403) | ||
| Hypotension (50.4 [61/121]) (403) | ||
| Gastrointestinal involvement | Mean 6.1 log copies/ml between days 10 and 15 for stool (156), with higher mean viral load in NPA obtained on day 10 significantly associated with diarrhea (58); 2.7 × 103-2.7 × 109 copies/ml between days 10 and 29 for small intestinal tissue and 5.3 × 103-3.7 × 108 copies/ml between days 10 and 43 for large intestinal tissue (96) | Minimal architectural disruption despite active viral replication in enterocytes of both terminal ileum and colonic biopsy specimens; no villous atrophy or inflammation (205); atrophy of mucosal lymphoid tissue (298) |
| Diarrhea (20.1 [130/647]) | ||
| Other symptoms | ||
| Myalgia (48.5 [365/752]) | Focal myofiber necrosis with scanty macrophage infiltration may be related to steroid treatment (204) | |
| Headache (38.8 [292/752]) | RT-PCR positive for some cerebrospinal fluid (188) | Necrosis of neuron cells and broad hyperplasia of gliocytes (389) |
| Dizziness (27.3 [163/597]) | ||
| Hematological involvement | Prolonged lymphopenia with nadir during days 7-9 returning to normal after 5 wk; death and severity are associated with profound CD4+ and CD8+ lymphopenia; little change in CD4/CD8 ratio (136) | |
| Anemia (12.6 [17/135]) | ||
| Leukopenia (24.2 [114/472]) | ||
| Lymphopenia (66.4 [296/446]) | ||
| Thrombocytopenia (29.7 [140/472]) | ||
| Biochemical involvement | ||
| Increased serum alanine aminotransferase levels (44.1 [208/472]) | Positive RT-PCR for liver tissue (44), 6 × 103-5 × 104 copies/ml between days 2 and 9 for liver tissue (96) | Ballooning of hepatocytes and mild to moderate lobular lymphocytic infiltration (44) |
| Impaired serum creatinine (6.7 [36/536]) (76) | Mean 1.3 log copies/ml between days 10 and 15 for urine (156) and 4.3 × 103-7.4 × 105 copies/ml between days 11 and 27 for kidney tissue (96) | Acute tubular necrosis (76) |
| Decreased serum tri-iodothyronine and thyroxine | Extensive cell apoptosis and exfoliation of the follicular epithelium into distorted, dilated, or collapsed follicles (354) | |
| Other | ||
| Histological orchitis (388) | Widespread germ cell destruction, few or no spermatozoa in the seminiferous tubule, thickened basement membrane, and leukocyte infiltration with T lymphocytes and macrophages in the interstitial tissue (388) |
| Diagnostic method and target gene | Clinical specimen | Diagnostic gold standard | Collection time after onset of symptoms (no. of samples) | % Sensitivity (viral load [copies/ml]) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| In-house RT-PCR | |||||
| RNA pola | NPA | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (72) | 59.7d | 391 |
| Days 1-5 (98) | 29.6 | 32 | |||
| RNA pol | NPA | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 0-5 (501) | 41.1 | 56 |
| Days 6-11 (211) | 58.8 | ||||
| Days 12-20 (62) | 37.1 | ||||
| Day >21 (15) | 13.3 | ||||
| RNA pol | Throat swab | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 1-13 (590) | 37.5 | 384 |
| RNA pola | Nose and throat swab | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (54) | 61.1d | 391 |
| Days 1-5 (53) | 28.3 | 32 | |||
| RNA pol | Upper respiratorye | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 0-5 (212) | 31.1 | 56 |
| Days 6-11 (73) | 37 | ||||
| Days 12-20 (45) | 31.1 | ||||
| Day >21 (159) | 5.7 | ||||
| RNA pola | Respiratoryf | Laboratory confirmedb | 1 wk (243) | 26.3 | 39 |
| 2 wk (134) | 30.6 | ||||
| 3-4 wk (94) | 18.1 | ||||
| RNA pol | Stool | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 5-10c (19) | 57.9d | 391 |
| Days 1-5 (25) | 20 | 32 | |||
| 1 wk (21) | 42.9 | 39 | |||
| 2 wk (25) | 68 | ||||
| 3-4 wk (80) | 42.5 | ||||
| RNA pol | Stool | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 0-5 (77) | 23.4 | 56 |
| Days 6-11 (86) | 57 | ||||
| Days 12-20 (72) | 52.8 | ||||
| Day >21 (297) | 15.2 | ||||
| RNA pol | Urine | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 5-10c (78) | 50d | 391 |
| Days 1-5 (15) | 0 | 32 | |||
| 1 wk (75) | 2.7 | 39 | |||
| 2 wk (82) | 6.1 | ||||
| 3-4 wk (54) | 11.1 | ||||
| RNA pol | Urine | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 0-11 (16) | 12.5 | 56 |
| Days 12-20 (21) | 4.8 | ||||
| Days >21-23 (161) | 1.9 | ||||
| RNA pol | Blood (serum) | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 0-5 (64) | 17.2 | 56 |
| Days 6-11 (14) | 35.7 | ||||
| Days 12-20 (9) | 11.1 | ||||
| Nested RNA pol | Blood (plasma) | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-3 (24) | 79.2 | 108 |
| In-house quantitative PCR | |||||
| ORF 1ba | NPA | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-3 (32) | 50 | 263 |
| Days 4-6 (35) | 31.4 | ||||
| Days 7-10 (31) | 51.6 | ||||
| ORF 1bg | NPA | Laboratory confirmedb | Day 1 (8) | 62.5d | 264 |
| Day 2 (16) | 87.5d | ||||
| Day 3 (26) | 80.1d | ||||
| ORF 1b | NPA | WHO criteria, probable SARS or laboratory confirmedb | Days 10-15 (142) | 42.3 (2.4 log [mean]) | 156 |
| 1-step ORF 1bg | NPA | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-3 (29) | 96.6d | 266 |
| Days 4-9 (57) | 80.7d | ||||
| 1-step ORF 1b | Throat wash | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-9 (17) | 9.58 × 102 (min)-5.93 × 106 (max) | 349 |
| Saliva | Days 2-9 (17) | 7.08 × 102 (min)-6.38 × 108 (max) | |||
| N | Respiratoryh | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (31) | 74.2 | 88 |
| N | NPA and stool | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 1-4 (32) | 18.8 | 155 |
| Days 5-10 (37) | 35.1 | ||||
| RNA pol | Stool | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-10 (8) | 75 | 189 |
| Days 11-20 (27) | 81.5 | ||||
| Days 21-30 (5) | 80 | ||||
| ORF 1b | Stool | WHO criteria, probable SARS or laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-3 (6) | 66.7 | 263 |
| Days 4-6 (15) | 80 | ||||
| Days 7-10 (16) | 62.5 | ||||
| Days 10-15 (94) | 87.2 (6.1 log [median]) | 156 | |||
| N | Stool | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 1-10 (37) | 27 | 413 |
| Days 11-20 (71) | 26.8 | ||||
| Days 21-30 (77) | 15.6 | ||||
| Days 31-40 (67) | 17.9 | ||||
| Day >40 (74) | 9.5 | ||||
| N | Stool | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (23) | 87 (5.5 × 104 [median]) | 88 |
| RNA pol | Urine | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-10 (14) | 7.1 | 189 |
| Days 11-20 (86) | 31.4 | ||||
| Days 21-30 (21) | 14.3 | ||||
| Days 31-60 (12) | 16.7 | ||||
| ORF 1b | Urine | WHO criteria, probable SARS or laboratory confirmedb | Days 10-15 (111) | 28.8 (1.3 log [mean]) | 156 |
| Blood (serum) | Days 10-15 (53) | 41.5 (1.1 log [mean]) | |||
| 1-step ORF 1bi | Blood (plasma) | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-4 (20) | 50 (2.36 × 103 [median])d | 349 |
| Days 5-7 (12) | 75 (6.91 × 103 [median])d | ||||
| Days 8-11 (11) | 63.6 (1.74 × 104 [median])d | ||||
| Days 12-16 (8) | 37.5 (3.83 × 103 [median])d | ||||
| N | Blood (plasma) | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (7) | 42.9 | 88 |
| N | Blood (whole blood) | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 1-10 (62) | 45.2 | 413 |
| Days 11-20 (41) | 48.8 | ||||
| Days 21-30 (165) | 13.3 | ||||
| Days 31-40 (158) | 16.5 | ||||
| In-house LAMPj | |||||
| ORF 1bg | NPA | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-3 (15) | 60d | 267 |
| Days 4-7 (37) | 70.3d | ||||
| Day >7 (7) | 100d | ||||
| 1-step replicase | Respiratory specimensk | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Day 3 (49) | 26.5d | 146 |
| Commercial quantitative PCR | |||||
| Roche kitl | Respiratoryh | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (30)m | 73.3 | 88 |
| Roche kit | NPA and throat swab | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (47) | 85d | 390 |
| Roche kit | Stool | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (23) | 78.3 (4.3 × 104 [median]) | 88 |
| Roche kit | Stool | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (32) | 88d | 390 |
| Commercial kitn | Stool | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Day ≤7 (13) | 46-62d | 230 |
| Days 8-21 (12) | 58-75d | ||||
| Day >21 (31) | 13-19d | ||||
| Roche kit | Urine | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (22) | 82d | 390 |
| Roche kit | Blood (plasma) | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (7) | 28.6 | 88 |
| Artus kito | Respiratoryh | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (31) | 74.2 | 88 |
| Artus kit | NPA and throat swab | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (47) | 87d | 390 |
| Artus kit | Stool | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (22)g | 81.8 | 88 |
| Artus kit | Stool | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (32) | 91d | 390 |
| Artus kit | Urine | Laboratory confirmedb | Days 1-5c (22) | 82d | 390 |
| Artus kit | Blood (plasma) | WHO criteria, laboratory-confirmed SARS | Days 2-54 (7) | 14.3 | 88 |
| Artus kit | Lung tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 5-51 (19) | 100 (2 × 104 [min]-1 × 1010 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Small bowel tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 10-29 (15) | 73 (2.7 × 103 [min]-2.7 × 109 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Large bowel tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 10-43 (15) | 73 (5.3 × 103 [min]-3.7 × 108 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Lymph node tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 14-34 (13) | 69 (1.5 × 104 [min]-8.9 × 108 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Liver tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 10-24 (17) | 41 (6 × 103 [min]-5 × 104 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Cardiac tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 5-23 (18) | 40 (1 × 104 [min]-2.8 × 107 [max]) | 96 |
| Artus kit | Kidney tissue | WHO criteria, probable SARS | Days 11-27 (16) | 38 (4.3 × 103 [min]-7.4 × 105 [max]) | 96 |
| Diagnostic method and detection target | Diagnostic gold standard | Collection time after onset of symptoms (days)a (no. of samples) | Sensitivity (%) | Overall specificity (%) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EIA | |||||
| N protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 3-5 (8) | 50 | 98.5 | 48 |
| 6-10 (14) | 71.4 | ||||
| 11-20 (9) | 44.4 | ||||
| N protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 1-5 (84) | 92.9 | 100 | 86 |
| 6-10 (63) | 69.8 | ||||
| 11-20 (52) | 30.8 | ||||
| N protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 1-5 (85) | 94 | 99.9 | 46 |
| 6-10 (60) | 78 | ||||
| N protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | NM (18) | 100 | 100 | 127 |
| N protein | Laboratory confirmedb | 6-24 (66) (NPA) | 52 | 96.7 | 191 |
| 11-31 (94) (urine) | 5 | 99 | |||
| 8-32 (65) (stool) | 55 | 96 | |||
| Immunofluorescence assay | |||||
| N protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 2-9 (17) (throat wash) | 65 | 100 | 226 |
| Diagnostic method and detection target | Diagnostic gold standard | Collection time (days) after onset of symptomsa (no. of samples) | Sensitivity (%) | Overall specificity (%) | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EIA | |||||
| Anti-N protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 1-5 (27) | 14.8 | 100 | 299 |
| 6-10 (38) | 68.4 | ||||
| 11-61 (135) | 89.6 | ||||
| Anti-N protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 10 (16) | 81.3 | 100 | 330 |
| 20 (16) | 100 | ||||
| 30 (16) | 100 | ||||
| Anti-N protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 12-72 (280) | 89.3 | NM | 273 |
| Anti-N protein antibodies | Laboratory confirmedb | 12-43 (106) | 95.3/96.6/96.6f | 94.3/59.4/60.4f | 373 |
| Anti-N protein antibodies | Laboratory confirmedb | NMc (106) | 94.3 | 100 | 369 |
| Anti-N protein antibodies | Laboratory confirmedd | First wk (36) (IgM) | 33 | 100 | 404 |
| Second wk (36) (IgM) | 97 | ||||
| Third wk (36) (IgM) | 100 | ||||
| Anti-N protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | NM (407) | 70.2 | 99.9 | 54 |
| Anti-N protein antibodies | Neutralization antibody assay | NM (276) | 92 | 92 | 294 |
| Anti-S protein antibodies | Laboratory confirmedb | 11-45 (95) | 58.9/74.7g | 98.6/93.9g | 374 |
| Anti-S protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | NM (51) | 80.4 | 100 | 423 |
| Anti-S2 protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | NM (20) | 85 | 100 | 350 |
| Anti-SARS-CoV antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | NM (56) | 96.4 | 100 | 297 |
| Antibodies against Gst-N and Gst-U274 | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 16-65 (74) | 100 | 99.5 | 115 |
| Antibodies against Gst-N and | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 1-10 (31) | 58 | 99.5 | 114 |
| Gst-U274 | 11-20 (120) | 70 | |||
| 21-30 (57) | 75.4 | ||||
| >30 (19) | 94.7 | ||||
| Immunochromatography | |||||
| Antibodies against Gst-N and Gst-U274 | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 1-10 (31) | 54.8 | 97.7 | 114 |
| 11-20 (120) | 68.3 | ||||
| 21-30 (57) | 80.7 | ||||
| >30 (19) | 78.9 | ||||
| Western blot assay | |||||
| Anti-N protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 4-76 (44) | 90.9 | 98.3 | 126 |
| Immunofluorescence assay | |||||
| Anti-SARS-CoV antibodies | True SARSe | 1-5 (64) (IgG) | 0 | 100 | 38 |
| 6-10 (35) (IgG) | 34.3 | ||||
| 11-15 (23) (IgG) | 78.3 | ||||
| 16-20 (43) (IgG) | 97.7 | ||||
| 21-37 (47) (IgG) | 100 | ||||
| Anti-S protein antibodies | WHO criteria, probable SARS | 7-14 (6) | 100 | 100 | 235 |
| 14-76 (15) | 100 | ||||
| Antibodies against N-S fusion protein | WHO criteria, probable SARS | >17 (23) | 95.6 | 100 | 128 |
| Antiviral agent and/or immunomodulator (no. of subjects) (study design) | Main findingsa | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Ribavirin (144 patients) (retrospective case series) | 126 patients (88%) treated; side effects of hemolysis (76%) and lowered hemoglobin of 2 g/dl (49%) | 21 |
| Ribavirin (229 patients) (retrospective uncontrolled cohort analysis) | 97 patients (42.2%) treated; crude death rate of 10.3% (treatment) vs 12.9% (control) (P = 0.679) | 199 |
| Ribavirin and corticosteroids (75 patients) (prospective case series) | 9 patients (12%) had spontaneous pneumomediastinum; 20% developed ARDS in wk 3 | 258 |
| Ribavirin and MP (31 patientsb) (retrospective case series) | No patient required intubation or mechanical ventilation; no mortality noted in this series | 303 |
| Ribavirin and corticosteroidsc (71 patientsd) (prospective cohort study) | Crude mortality rate of 3.4% (only in patients aged >65 yr); none of the discharged survivors required continuation of oxygen therapy | 186 |
| Ribavirin and corticosteroidse (138 patients) (prospective uncontrolled study) | None responded to antibacterials; 25 patients (18.1%) responded to ribavirin and low-dose corticosteroid; 107 patients required high-dose MP, 88.8% of whom responded; 21 patients (15.2%) required mechanical ventilation; mortality rate, 10.9% | 314 |
| Ribavirin and MP (72 patientsf) (retrospective uncontrolled study) | Patients treated with initial pulse MP therapy had no better rate on mechanical ventilation (5.9% vs 9.1%) (NS) and mortality (5.9% vs 5.5%) (NS) | 139 |
| Lopinavir-ritonavir and ribavirin (41 patients) (retrospective study with historical control)g | ARDS and death were lower in treatment group than in historical control (2.4% vs 28.8%) (P < 0.001) at day 21 after symptom onset | 72 |
| Lopinavir-ritonavir as initial therapy (44 patients) (retrospective matched cohort study)h | Intubation rate of 0% vs 11% (P < 0.05); mortality rate of 2.3% vs 15.6% (P < 0.05) | 33 |
| Lopinavir-ritonavir as rescue therapy (31 patients) (retrospective matched cohort study)i | Intubation rate of 9.7% vs 18.1% (NS); mortality rate of 12.9% vs 14% (NS) | 33 |
| IFN-alfacon-1 and corticosteroids (22 patients) (open-label study) | 9 patients (40.9%) were treated; 1 (11.1%) patient required mechanical ventilation, and no patient died; of 13 patients (59.1%) treated with corticosteroid alone, 3 (23.1%) required mechanical ventilation and 1 (7.7%) died | 231 |
| Pentaglobin, an IgM-enriched immunoglobulin (12 patientsj) (retrospective analysis) | Improvement in radiographic scores compared with day 1 (median, 9.5) on days 6 (median, 6) (P = 0.01) and 7 (median, 6) (P = 0.01) and in oxygen requirement compared with day 1 (median, 2.5 liters/min) on days 6 (median, 1 liter/min) (P = 0.04) and 7 (median, 0.5 liters/min) (P = 0.04) after commencement of pentaglobin treatment | 140 |
| Convalescent plasma (1 patientk) (case report) | Convalescent plasma (200 ml) was given at day 15 after onset of illness without adverse reaction; patient recovered uneventfully | 366 |
| Convalescent plasma (3 patients) | Viral load decreased from 4.9 × 105-6.5 × 105 copies/ml to undetectable 1 day after transfusion | 401 |
| Convalescent plasma (80 patients) | A higher day 22 discharge rate was observed in patients treated before day 14 of illness (58.3% vs 15.6%) (P < 0.001), and in patients with positive PCR, SARS-CoV antibodies were negative at the time of plasma infusion (66.7% vs 20%) (P = 0.001) | 60 |
| Two herbal formulas (Sang Ju Yin and Yu Ping Feng San) (37 healthy volunteers) | Given oral traditional Chinese medicine regimen daily for 14 days with transient increase in CD4/CD8 ratio | 269 |
| Antiviral agent(s) and/or immunomodulator(s) | Study setting and methods (virus strain) | Main findingsa | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| IFN-αB/D (hybrid IFN) | BALB/c mice (Urbani) | i.p. IFN-αB/D once daily for 3 days beginning 4 h after virus exposure reduced SARS-CoV replication in lungs by 1 log10 at 10,000 and 32,000 IU; at the highest dose of 100,000 IU, virus lung titers were not detectable | 13 |
| Ampligen [poly(I:C124)] (mismatched double-stranded RNA IFN inducer) | BALB/c mice (Urbani) | i.p. Ampligen at 10 mg/kg 4 h after virus exposure reduced virus lung titers to undetectable levels | 13 |
| Pegylated IFN-α as prophylactic treatment | Cynomolgus macaques (Macaca fascicularis) (patient 5668) | Significantly reduced viral replication and excretion, viral antigen expression by type 1 pneumocytes, and pulmonary damage; postexposure treatment with pegylated IFN-α yielded intermediate results | 118 |
| IFN-α2b (Intron A) | Vero (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 4,950 (890) IU/ml (SI of >2) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = 6,500 (980) IU/ml (SI of >105) for HK isolate | 78 |
| Caco2 (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 1,530 (220) IU/ml (SI of >6.5) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = 880 (130) IU/ml (SI of >11.4) for HK isolate | 78 | |
| IFN-β1b (Betaferon) | Vero (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 95 (17) IU/ml (SI of >105) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = 105 (21) IU/ml (SI of >95) for HK isolate | 78 |
| Caco2 (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 21 (3.9) IU/ml (SI of >476) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = 9.2 (2.1) IU/ml (SI of >1,087) for HK isolate | 78 | |
| IFN-γ1b (Imukin) | Vero (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 2,500 (340) IU/ml (SI of >4) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = 1,700 (290) IU/ml (SI of >5.9) for HK isolate | 78 |
| Caco2 (FFM-1, HK isolate) | Mean (SD) EC50 = >10,000 IU/ml (SI NA) for FFM-1 isolate; mean (SD) EC50 = >10,000 IU/ml (SI NA) for HK isolate | 78 | |
| IFN-β1a | Vero E6 (Tor2, Tor7, and Urbani) | IFN with p.i. IC50 = 50 IU/ml; IFN added postinfection IC50 = 500 IU/ml | 137 |
| IFN-β, IFN-α, IFN-γ | Vero, MxA-expressing Vero (FFM-1) | SARS-CoV strongly inhibited by IFN-β (with p.i.) and less so with IFN-α and IFN-γ; MxA does not interfere with viral replication | 305 |
| IFN-α, IFN-β | FRhK-4 (NMf) | ↓ intracellular viral RNA copies; IFN-α IC50 = 25 U/ml; IFN-β IC50 = 14 U/ml | 426 |
| IFN-α2b | Vero E6 (Tor2, Tor3, Tor7, and Tor684) | IC50 = ∼500 IU/ml | 308 |
| Leu-IFN-α | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 5,000 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 19.5 μg/ml | 50 | |
| IFN-α (p.i. for 16 h before viral inoculation) | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 39 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 19.5 μg/ml | 50 | |
| IFN-β | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 200 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 106 μg/ml | 50 | |
| IFN-β (p.i. for 16 h before viral inoculation) | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 625 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 19.5 μg/ml | 50 | |
| IFN-β1b (Betaferon) | Vero E6 (2003VA2774) | IC50 = 0.2 IU/ml; IC95 = 8 IU ml | 318 |
| IFN-αn3 (Alferon) | Vero E6 (2003VA2774) | IC50 = 0.8 IU/ml; IC95 = 200 IU/ml | 318 |
| Human leukocyte IFN-α (Multiferon) | Vero E6 (2003VA2774) | IC50 = 2 IU/ml; IC95 = 44 IU/ml | 318 |
| IFN-β | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = 110 IU/ml at 10 TCID50; IC50 = 625 IU/ml at 100 TCID50 | 83 |
| Multiferon | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = 540 IU/ml at 10 TCID50; IC50 = 2,400 IU/ml at 100 TCID50 | 83 |
| IFN-α2b | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = >3,125 IU/ml at 10 TCID50; IC50 = >3,125 IU/ml at 100 TCID50 | 83 |
| IFN-α2a | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = >3,125 IU/ml at 10 TCID50; IC50 = >3,125 IU/ml at 100 TCID50 | 83 |
| IFN-alfacon1 (Infergen) | Vero (Urbani) | IC50 = 0.001 μg/ml | 257 |
| IL-4 and IFN-γ | Vero E6 (HKU39849) | IL-4 and IFN-γ downregulated cell surface expression of ACE2; ACE2 mRNA levels were also decreased after treatment | 84 |
| IFN-β and ribavirin | Caco2 (FFM-1) | Mean (SD) CI = 0.45 (0.07) | 243 |
| HR2-8 (HR2-derived peptide) | Vero 118 (NM) | EC50 = 17 μM | 22 |
| CP-1 (HR2-derived peptide) | Vero E6 (WHU) | IC50 ≈ 19 μmol/liter | 227 |
| HR1-1 (HR1-derived peptide) | Vero E6 (BJ01 and pseudovirus) | EC50 = 3.68 μM for wild-type virus assay; EC50 = 0.14 μM for pseudotyped virus assay | 407 |
| HR2-18 (HR2-derived peptide) | Vero E6 (BJ01 and pseudovirus) | EC50 = 5.22 μM for wild-type virus assay; EC50 = 1.19 μM for pseudotyped virus assay | 407 |
| HR2 | Vero E6 (WHU) | CPE inhibition IC50 = 0.5-5 nM (synthetic HR2 peptide) and 66.2-500 nM (fusion HR2 peptide) | 432 |
| Peptides representing various regions of ACE2 | TELCeB6, HeLa, and VeroE6 (pseudovirus) | IC50 = 50 μM (peptide aa 22-44); IC50 = 6 μM (peptide aa 22-57); IC50 = 0.1 μM (peptide aa 22-44 and 351-357) artificially linked by glycine | 120 |
| Peptides analogous to viral spike protein | Vero E6, L2 (Urbani) | Inhibit viral plaque formation by 40-70% at 15-30 μM; peptides analogous to regions of the N terminus or the pretransmembrane domain of the S2 subunit; inhibit viral plaque formation by >80% at 15-30 μM (peptides analogous to the SARS-CoV loop region) | 295 |
| siRNA, RL004, RL005 | Vero E6 (Y3) | siRNA (600 pmol/liter) targeting conserved regions of SARS-CoV, ↓ virally induced CPE at 67 h | 418 |
| siRNA | FRhK-4 (HKU66078) | siRNA duplexes targeting regions in entire viral genome, ↓ virally induced CPE and viral production at 72 h | 428 |
| siRNA targeting viral RP | Vero (NM) | ↓ virally induced CPE, ↓ viral production, ↓ viral protein synthesis at 1.5 or 3 μg of siRNA | 351 |
| RNA interference targeting viral RP | Vero E6, 293, HeLa (SARS-CoV-p9) | ↓ expression of RP (293 and HeLa cells); ↓ plaque formation at 1 μg of siRNA | 232 |
| siRNA targeting S gene | Vero E6, 293T (BJ01) | ↓ S gene expression in SARS-CoV-infected cells at 2, 3, and 4 μg of siRNA | 419 |
| siRNAs targeting S gene and 3′ untranslated region | Vero E6 (HK strain) | ↓ viral antigen synthesis of 64% (by siSARS-S2), 51% (siSARS-S3), 40% (siSARS 3′ untranslated region) at 100 pmol of siRNA | 379 |
| Glycyrrhizin | Vero (FFM-1, FFM-2) | CPE assay mean (SD) CC50 = >20,000 mg/liter; EC50 = 300 (51) mg/liter (SI of >67) | 77 |
| FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = >400 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 100 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Mizoribine | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = 3.5 μg/ml; CC50 = >200 μg/ml | 293 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39489) | IC50 = 16 μg/ml | 293 | |
| Ribavirin | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | IC50 = 20 μg/ml; CC50 = >200 μg/ml | 293 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39489) | IC50 = 80 μg/ml | 293 | |
| FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 50-100 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = >200 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Rimantidine | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 16 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 8-16 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Lopinavir | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 16 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 8-16 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Baicalin | FRhK-4 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 12.5 μg/ml | 50 |
| Vero E6 (HKU39849) | EC50 at 48 h = 100 μg/ml | 50 | |
| Aurintricarboxylic acid | Vero (NM) | EC50 = 0.2 mg/ml; CC50 = 37.5 mg/ml; SI = 187 | 129 |
| Reserpine | Vero E6 (HK strain) | EC50 = 3.4 μM; CC50 = 25 μM; SI = 7.3 | 381 |
| Aescin | Vero E6 (HK strain) | EC50 = 6 μM; CC50 = 15 μM; SI = 2.5 | 381 |
| Valinomycin | Vero E6 (HK strain) | EC50 = 0.85 μM; CC50 = 68 μM; SI = 80 | 381 |
| Niclosamide | Vero E6 (Taiwan strain) | EC50 = 1-3 μM; CC50 = 250 μM | 380 |
| Nelfinavir | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 0.048 (0.024) μM; CC50 = 14.75 (2.75) μM; SI = 302.1 | 392 |
| Chloroquine | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | Mean (SD) IC50 = 8.8 (1.2) μM; CC50 = 261.3 (14.5) μM; SI = 30 | 174 |
| Vero E6 (Urbani) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 4.4 (1.0) μM; refractory to infection if pretreated with chloroquine (10 μM) for 20 h | 341 | |
| Indomethacin | Vero E6 (Tor2) | IC50 = 50 μM | 4 |
| 3C-like proteinase inhibitors | |||
| Cinanserin (SQ 10,643) | Vero (NM) | IC50 = 5 μM | 51 |
| TG-0205221 | Vero E6 (NM) | ↓ viral load by 4.7 logs at 5 μM | 396 |
| Octapeptide AVLQSGFR | Vero (BJ01) | EC50 = 0.027 mg/liter; CC50 = >100 mg/liter; SI = >3,704 | 101 |
| Peptidomimetic inhibitor | NM | IC50 = 45-70 μM | 103 |
| Calpain inhibitors, Val-Leu-CHO | Vero E6 (Urbani) | EC90 = 3 μM | 14 |
| Calpain inhibitors, Z-Val-Phe-Ala-CHO | Vero E6 (Urbani) | EC90 = 15 μM | 14 |
| Cyclopentenyl carbocyclic nucleosides | NM | EC50 = 47 μM for 1,2,3-triazole analogue (17c); EC50 = 21 μM for 1,2,4-triazole analogue (17a) | 65 |
| Nucleoside analogue inhibitor, β-d-N4-hydroxycytidine | Vero E6 (Urbani) | EC90 = 6 μM | 14 |
| Nitric oxide, S-nitroso-N-acetylpenicillamine | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | Mean (SD) IC50 = 222 (83.7) μM; SI = 3 | 173 |
| Pyridine N-oxide derivatives | Crandel feline kidney (CRFK) and Vero (FFM-1) | Among 192 compounds tested, the oxide part on pyridine moiety was indispensable for antiviral activity with CC50 of 50-100 mg/liter | 11 |
| Stilbene derivatives | Vero E6 (NM) | Inhibited by compounds 17 and 19 at 0.5 mg/ml, and no significant cytotoxic effects were observed in vitro | 217 |
| Peptide-conjugated antisense morpholino oligomers (P-PMO) | Vero E6 (Tor2) | Several virus-targeted P-PMO (AUG1, AUG2, AUG3, 1AFBS, and 3UTR) consistently reduced CPE at a concn of 20 μM | 246 |
| 20-mer synthetic peptides (S protein fragments) | FRhK-4 (GZ50) | IC50 = 24.9-113 μg/ml; IC90 = 0.9-15.9 μg/ml | 427 |
| Diverse small molecules,b MP576, HE602, and VE607 | Vero (HKU39849) | EC50 = <10 μM | 170 |
| Adamantane-derived compoundsc | FRhK-4 (NM) | IC50 = 0.5-3 μM; CC50 = >300 μM | 328 |
| Semisynthetic derivatives of glycopeptide | |||
| Vancomycin | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | EC50 = 22->100 μM; CC50 = >80 μM | 10 |
| Eremomycin | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | EC50 = 14->100 μM; CC50 = 45->100 μM | 10 |
| Teicoplanin, ristocetin A, and DA-40926 | Vero E6 (FFM-1) | EC50 = >80 μM; CC50 = >80 μM | 10 |
| Lycoris radiata (Chinese medicinal herb) | Vero E6 (BJ001, BJ006) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 2.4 (0.2) μg/ml; CC50 = 886.6 (35.0) μg/ml | 212 |
| Artemisia annua (Chinese medicinal herb) | Vero E6 (BJ001, BJ006) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 34.5 (2.6) μg/ml; CC50 = 1,035 (92.8) μg/ml | 212 |
| Pyrrosia lingua (Chinese medicinal herb) | Vero E6 (BJ001, BJ006) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 43.2 (14.1) μg/ml; CC50 = 2,378 (87.3) μg/ml | 212 |
| Lindera sp. (Chinese medicinal herb) | Vero E6 (BJ001, BJ006) | Mean (SD) EC50 = 88.2 (7.7) μg/ml; CC50 = 1,374 (39.0) μg/ml | 212 |
| Type of vaccine | Target (animal model) | Responsea | Reference(s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Passive immunization | |||
| Human monoclonal antibody | S protein (ferret) | Decrease in lung viral titer, decrease in viral shedding, prevention of virally induced tissue pathology | 329 |
| S protein (BALB/c mice) | Decrease in lung/nasal viral titers | 333 | |
| S protein (BALB/c mice) | Decrease in lung viral titers | 313 | |
| Human monoclonal antibody from transgenic (HuMantibody) mice | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Decrease in lung/nasal viral titers | 110 |
| Active immunization | |||
| Inactivated whole virus | Inactivated SARS-CoV (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies | 323 |
| Inactivated SARS-CoV (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies; specific IgA in tracheal/lung wash fluid with adjuvant-added or PEG-precipitated vaccine only | 274 | |
| Inactivated SARS-CoV (BALB/c mice, rabbits) | Specific antibodies recognizing RBD of S1; blocked binding of RBD to ACE2; significant decrease in S protein-mediated cell entry in pseudotyped virus assay | 134 | |
| Inactivated SARS-CoV (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies | 306, 317 | |
| Recombinant protein fragment | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies | 19 |
| S protein (BALB/c mice, rabbits) | Neutralizing antibodies | 415 | |
| S protein (rabbits) | Neutralizing antibodies against receptor binding domain | 133 | |
| S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies against receptor binding domain | 132 | |
| Adenoviral vector | S, M, and N proteins (rhesus macaques) | Neutralizing antibodies, T-cell responses | 102 |
| Modified vaccinia virus Ankara | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies; decrease in lung/nasal viral titers, passive serum transfer protective | 18 |
| S protein (BALB/c mice, rabbits, Chinese rhesus monkeys) | Neutralizing antibodies; decrease in lung/nasal viral titers | 55 | |
| S protein (ferrets) | Neutralizing antibodies; enhanced hepatitis in vaccinated ferrets when challenged with SARS-CoV | 355 | |
| Recombinant attenuated HPIF3 | S protein (African green monkey) | Neutralizing antibodies, decrease in viral shedding | 25 |
| Recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies, decrease in lung viral titer | 171 |
| Attenuated rabies virus | S or N protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies specific to S but not with N protein | 94 |
| Recombinant Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus replicon particle | S or N protein (young and senescent BALB/c mice) | Good protection in young but partial protection in senescent mice with S vaccine; enhanced immunopathology with N vaccine | 85 |
| DNA vaccine | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies, T-cell responses; decrease in lung/nasal viral titers; serum transfer protective | 399 |
| S protein (BALB/c mice) | Neutralizing antibodies, T-cell responses | 123, 412 | |
| E, M, and N proteins (BALB/c mice) | DNA encoding N induced highest neutralizing antibodies and T-cell responses | 164 | |
| N protein (C3H/He mice) | Specific antibodies, T-cell responses | 433 | |
| N protein (C57BL/6 mice) | T-cell responses; decrease in surrogate viral titer in lungs | 176 | |
| S protein (rabbits) | Neutralizing antibodies | 348 | |
| N protein (mice) | Specific antibodies, N-specific splenocyte proliferation responses, DTH and CD8+ CTL responses | 424 | |
| DNA vaccine boosted by recombinant protein produced in E. coli | S protein (BALB/c mice) | Very high S-specific neutralizing antibodies | 370 |
| Animal species and age | Dose and route of inoculation (virus strain) | Point of evaluation (days) | Main findings | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cynomolgus macaques (Macaca fascicularis) | 103 to 106 TCID50; i.n., i.v., conjunctival (NM) | Up to 16 | Lethargy from 3 dpi, respiratory distress from 4 dpi, died with severe multifocal pulmonary consolidation and histologically interstitial pneumonia, diffuse alveolar damage, necrosis of alveolar and bronchiolar epithelium, and alveolar edema with proteinaceous fluid admixed with fibrin, erythrocytes, alveolar macrophages, and neutrophils | 98 |
| Cynomolgus macaques (Macaca fascicularis); adult | 106 TCID50; i.n., IT, conjunctiva (strain from patient 5688) | 6 | Excreted SARS-CoV from nose, mouth, and pharynx from 2 dpi; diffuse alveolar damage with epithelial necrosis, serosanguineous exudate, hyaline membrane formation, type 2 pneumocyte hyperplasia, and syncytium formation | 182 |
| Cynomolgus macaques and rhesus macaques | 107 PFU; IT, i.v. (Tor2) | 12 | Mild self-limited respiratory infection | 291 |
| African green, rhesus, and cynomolgus monkeys; juvenile | 106 TCID50; i.n., IT (Urbani) | Up to 28 | SARS-CoV replicated in the respiratory tract but did not induce illness; moderate to high titers of SARS-CoV excretion with associated interstitial pneumonitis detected in lungs of African green monkeys on 2 dpi and resolved by 4 dpi | 239 |
| Rhesus macaques (Macaca mulatta); 1-3 yr | 103, 105, 107 TCID50; i.n. (PUMC01) | Up to 60 | Transient fever occurred 2-3 dpi; SARS-CoV-specific IgGs detected in sera of macaques from 11 to 60 dpi; SARS-CoV RNA detected in pharyngeal swab samples 5 dpi; histopathological changes of interstitial pneumonia during the 60 dpi | 272 |
| Cynomolgus macaques (Macaca fascicularis); adult | 1.25 × 106 PFU; i.n., i.v., conjunctiva (Urbani) | Up to 20 | Mild to moderate symptomatic illness; evidence of viral replication and neutralizing antibodies; chest X-ray unifocal or multifocal pneumonia peaked between 8 and 10 dpi; inoculation by mucosal route produced more prominent disease than that with i.v. inoculation | 194 |
| BALB/c mice; 4 wk | 2 × 105 TCID50; i.n., oral (Urbani) | 3, 5, 7, 10, and 28 | Viral replication in lung and intestinal tissue but caused subclinical infection or very mild disease | 357 |
| BALB/c mice; 4-6 wk | 105 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani) | 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, and 11 | Peak replication in the absence of disease on 1 or 2 dpi; viral clearance within a wk; viral antigen and nucleic acid detected in bronchiolar epithelial cells during peak viral replication | 311 |
| C57BL/6 mice; 5-6 wk | 104 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani) | Up to 15 | Infected mice had transient infection with relative failure to thrive; viral replication to high levels in lungs of these mice, which peaked on 3 dpi and cleared by day 9 dpi | 105 |
| BALB/c mice; 12-14 mo | 105 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani) | 1, 2, 5, 9, and 13 | Viral replication in aged mice was associated with clinical illness and pneumonia demonstrating an age-related susceptibility to SARS disease | 287 |
| 129SvEv mice (Stat1+/−) | 106 PFU; i.n. (Tor2) | 1, 3, 5, 8, 11, 15, and 22 | Stat1-deficient mice had viral replication of virus in lungs and progressively worsening pulmonary disease with inflammation of small airways and alveoli and systemic viral spread to livers and spleens | 143 |
| BALB/c mice; 6-8 wk | 105 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani of 15 passages [MA15] in BALB/c mice) | 6 | Lethality preceded by high-titer viral replication in lungs, viremia, and dissemination to extrapulmonary sites accompanied by lymphopenia, neutrophilia, and pathological changes in lungs; death from an overwhelming viral infection with extensive virally mediated destruction of pneumocytes and ciliated epithelial cells; the MA15 virus has six coding mutations (in Orf1a, Orf1b, S gene, and M gene) associated with adaptation and increased virulence | 286 |
| Transgenic mice expressing hACE2 (K18-hACE2) | 2.3 × 102-2.3 × 104 PFU; i.n. (Urbani) | 7b | Weight loss by 3-5 dpi and died by 7 dpi; infection begins in airway epithelia with subsequent alveolar involvement and extrapulmonary virus spread to the brain; infection results in macrophage and lymphocyte infiltration in the lungs and up-regulation of proinflammatory cytokines and chemokines in both the lung and the brain | 240 |
| Transgenic mice expressing hACE2 (AC70) | 103 or 2 × 105 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani) | 8 | Developed acute wasting syndrome and died within 4-8 dpi; high levels of virus replication detected in lungs and brain; pathological examination suggests that the extensive involvement of the central nervous system likely contributed to the death of mice, even though viral pneumonia was present | 337 |
| F344 rat; adult | 100 μlc; i.n. (Frankfurt 1 after 10 passages)d | 3, 5, 7, and 21 | Adult rats showed respiratory symptoms and severe pathological lung lesions; inflammatory cytokine levels in sera and lung tissues were significantly higher in adult than in young rats | 244 |
| Golden Syrian hamsters; 5 wk | 103 TCID50; i.n. (Urbani) | 2, 3, 5, 7, 10, and 14 | Little clinical evidence of disease; viral replication in epithelial cells of the respiratory tract with early cellular necrosis, followed by an inflammatory response coincident with viral clearance; focal consolidation in lung; viremia and extrapulmonary spread of SARS-CoV to liver and spleen despite high levels of virus replication and associated pathology | 288 |
| Common marmosets (Callithrix jacchus), small nonhuman primate; juvenile or young adult | 106 TCID50; IT (Urbani) | 2, 4, and 7 | Mild clinical disease; multifocal mononuclear cell interstitial pneumonitis, multinucleated syncytial cells, edema, and bronchiolitis; viral antigen localized to infected alveolar macrophages and type 1 pneumocytes; viral RNA detected in all animals from pulmonary tissue and in some cases from tracheobronchial lymph node and myocardium with inflammatory changes; multifocal lymphocytic hepatitis with piecemeal necrosis | 111 |
| Cats | 106 TCID50; IT (patient 5688) | 4 | Asymptomatic shedding of virus from pharynx | 237 |
| Ferrets | 106 TCID50; IT (patient 5688) | 4 | 3 out of 6 ferrets became lethargic from 2-4 dpi with viral replication and pneumonitis | 237 |
| Ferrets (Mustela putorius furo) | 106 TCID50; i.n. (Tor2) | Up to 29 | Asymptomatic viral replication but significant hepatitis occurred only after vaccination with modified vaccinia virus Ankara carrying SARS-CoV spike protein | 355 |
| Masked palm civets (Paguma larvata); 1 yr | 3 × 106 TCID50; i.n., IT (BJ01e and GZ01f) | 0, 3, 8, 13, 18, 23, 28, and 33 | Fever, lethargy, and loss of aggressiveness; infection was confirmed by virus isolation, detection of viral genomic RNA, and serum neutralizing antibodies | 382 |
| Guinea pigs | Up to 104.7 TCID50; i.p. (coinfected with SARS-CoV and reovirus) | NM | Guinea pigs infected with SARS-CoV developed only interstitial pneumonitis without clinical diseases; death and severe pulmonary pathology were seen in those coinfected with reovirus | 219 |
| Chicken; 6 wk | 106 PFU; i.n., i.v., oral, ocular (Tor3) | 6, 7, 13, 14, 15, and 16 | No disease, pathology, or viral shedding; no antibody response | 356 |
| Pigs; 6 wk | 2 × 106 PFU; i.n., i.v., oral, ocular (Tor3) | 6, 7, 13, 14, 15, and 16 | No disease, pathology, or viral shedding; neutralizing antibodies present | 356 |
| Himalayan palm civet | Natural infection | NA | Viral shedding demonstrated by culture and RT-PCR in nasal and fecal samples; sequence analysis showed that all animal isolates retain a 29-nucleotide sequence not found in most human isolates | 117 |
| Raccoon dog (Nyctereutes procyonoides) | Natural infection | NA | Viral shedding demonstrated by culture and RT-PCR in nasal and fecal samples; sequence analysis showed that all animal isolates retain a 29-nucleotide sequence not found in most human isolates | 117 |
| Bats (Rhinolophus sinicus) | Natural infection | NA | Coronavirus closely related to SARS-CoV (bat SARS-CoV) in 39% of anal swabs by using RT-PCR with a viral load of 3.89 × 102-2.21 × 107; bat SARS-CoV genome is closely related to SARS-CoV from humans and civets; antibody against recombinant bat SARS-CoV nucleocapsid protein was detected in 84% of Chinese horseshoe bats | 190 |
| Bats (family Rhinolophidae) | Natural infection | NA | SARS-CoV antibody in 28.3% of Rhinolophus pearsoni and 33.3% of Rhinolophus pussilus isolates from Guangxi and 71% of Rhinolophus macrotis isolates from Hubei; RT-PCR positive for a SARS-like virus in 12.5% of Rhinolophus ferrumequinum and 12.5% of R. macrotis isolates from Hubei and 10% of R. pearsoni isolates from Guangxi | 215 |
Acknowledgments
REFERENCES
Information & Contributors
Information
Published In


