INTRODUCTION
Mycosphaerella graminicola (
Zymoseptoria tritici) is an ascomycete filamentous fungus and is the causative pathogen of Septoria leaf blotch in wheat crops. This is the most common cereal crop disease in Europe and can result in devastating losses in crop yield (
1,
2). Currently the most widely used fungicides for the control of
M. graminicola are demethylase inhibitors (DMIs), which bind to the target cytochrome P450 enzyme, CYP51 (ERG11).
CYP51s are ubiquitous in nature and mediate the essential sterol 14α-demethylation step in the sterol biosynthetic pathway (
3). The 14α-demethylated products are precursors leading to formation of cholesterol (mammals) and ergosterol (fungi) and the formation of a variety of 24-alkylated and desaturated sterols in algae, plants, and protozoa (
3). Cholesterol, ergosterol, and sitosterols (plants) play an important structural role in regulating membrane fluidity and permeability of plasma membranes and indirectly modulate the distribution and activity of membrane proteins and ion channels (
3,
4). In addition, sterols are precursors of steroid hormones in mammals, brassinosteroids in plants, and ecdysteroids in insects. In yeast and fungi, the CYP51 enzymes are synonymous with lanosterol and eburicol 14α-demethylation in the production of ergosterol, but as this study shows,
M. graminicola CYP51 is able to demethylate only eburicol, in the presence of its native reductase partner, exhibiting novel substrate specificity.
The introduction of new azole antifungal compounds has allowed control of
M. graminicola infections in wheat to be maintained despite increased tolerance/resistance. The most recently introduced azole is the triazolinethione derivative prothioconazole. However, the control of this disease has been threatened by the identification of mutations in the CYP51 enzyme that are recognized for being involved in
M. graminicola populations developing resistance to these fungicides (
5,
6). Similar mutations in the CYP51 enzyme have also been observed in the clinical setting with
Candida albicans and are responsible for azole-resistant infections in patients (
7,
8). Therefore, understanding the biochemical nature of the CYP51 enzyme from
M. graminicola and its interactions with azole antifungal drugs is paramount to agricultural economics and food security.
NADPH cytochrome P450 reductase (CPR) is the main redox partner for CYP51 (and other eukaryotic cytochromes P450) and is essential for functional metabolism. CPR is a flavoprotein containing equal amounts of the cofactors flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD) and flavin mononucleotide (FMN), each localized within its own structural domain joined together by an α-helical peptide bridge region. CPR catalyzes the transfer of two electrons from exogenous NADPH to the FAD prosthetic group and then to the FMN prosthetic group before donating electrons in two discrete one-electron steps to the CYP acceptor (
9). This is known as the cytochrome P450 catalytic cycle. Most eukaryotes, including
M. graminicola, contain only one CPR gene, which must be able to interact with and reduce the wide and divergent range of CYPs present within each organism.
In this study, we have cloned, expressed, and purified the CPR enzyme from M. graminicola (MgCPR) and have successfully reconstituted the CPR enzyme with the native CYP51 enzyme from M. graminicola in order to catalyze the 14α-demethylation of eburicol. In contrast to other fungal CYP51 proteins studied so far, we demonstrate specificity for eburicol in the reaction, and we speculate on the reason for the lack of activity with the substrate lanosterol. In addition, we have demonstrated the effectiveness of several agricultural azole fungicides at inhibiting the CYP51 reaction catalyzed by the MgCPR/MgCYP51 redox pairing, thus producing a functional method to evaluate the effects of potential new DMIs on MgCYP51.
DISCUSSION
Septoria leaf blotch is a major cause of economic losses in agriculture due to fungal infection and is controlled by azole fungicides, more recently the triazolinethione derivative prothioconazole. Controlling this disease is, therefore, crucial for food security. Azole antifungal drugs cause accumulation of 14-methylated sterols and cell growth inhibition, with a block to ergosterol production. Interestingly, the major sterol accumulating during treatment is eburicol (
6). This is consistent with the novel observation in this study that eburicol is the substrate of choice for MgCYP51; usually fungal CYP51s can also metabolize lanosterol. Eburicol is produced by 24-methylation of lanosterol, which is the preferred substrate for 24-methyl transferase, so this is presumably required in the natural pathway, leading to the production of ergosterol in
M. graminicola. The overexpression of the MgCPR protein described here has allowed a functional reconstitution system to be developed in which eburicol was a prerequisite, and it leads the way for the use of pathogen-relevant assays for fungicide discovery.
The successful overexpression of MgCPR in
E. coli resulted in a protein yield that was half the 160 nmol liter
−1 obtained for
C. albicans CPR (
20) and 10-fold less than the 840 nmol liter
−1 obtained for
P. chrysosporium CPR (
23), but it was 10-fold greater than the 7.5 nmol liter
−1 recovered for native
S. cerevisiae CPR (
24). The kinetic properties of MgCPR using the one-electron reduction of oxidized cytochrome
c with NADPH as a redox partner (
Fig. 3) were similar to those observed previously with other eukaryotic CPR enzymes. In contrast to the one-electron reduction of cytochrome
c, the reduction of cytochrome P450 monooxygenases by CPR is a two-electron process that involves two discrete one-electron transfers during the cytochrome P450 catalytic cycle (
25). Previously, it has been shown that N-terminally truncated rat and human CPR enzymes could catalyze the reduction of cytochrome
c but could not support cytochrome P450 catalysis (
12,
26,
27). Therefore, it was important to establish that MgCPR also supported CYP51 catalysis. MgCPR acts as redox partner to
C. albicans CYP51, but surprisingly, the redox pairing of MgCPR and MgCYP51 failed to demethylate both eburicol and lanosterol at 37°C. However, the MgCYP51-catalyzed demethylation of eburicol was observed by reducing the incubation temperature to 22°C (0.13 min
−1), indicating that MgCYP51 catalysis was more temperature sensitive than
C. albicans CYP51. These differences in temperature correlate to the biological growth of both organisms;
C. albicans grows at 37°C in both the host and the laboratory, whereas the optimal growth temperature for
M. graminicola is ∼25°C (mycelial growth). The inability of the MgCPR/MgCYP51 pairing to demethylate lanosterol suggests that MgCYP51 is an eburicol-dependent CYP51 enzyme, a finding supported by
in silico experimentation. The modeling experiments suggested that lanosterol could fit into the active site, as supported by the type I binding spectra, but could not orientate the C-14-methyl group to facilitate catalysis, unlike for eburicol. This study is the first demonstration of selectivity and sterol specificity for a fungal CYP51, although obtusifoliol specificity (
28) has been seen in plant and trypanosomal studies (
29).
The MgCYP51
Km for eburicol was 3-fold higher than the previously calculated
Ks value of 11 μM for eburicol binding to MgCYP51 by UV-visible spectroscopy (
16) suggesting that the
Km value is not solely dependent on the affinity of MgCYP51 for substrate. The MgCYP51
Km value for eburicol was comparable with that determined for human CYP51 of 30 μM with lanosterol (
30) but was 4- to 6-fold larger than
Km values previously determined for
C. albicans and
S. cerevisiae CYP51 enzymes (
15,
31,
32), suggesting a degree of variability with regard to substrate affinity among CYP51 enzymes.
Previously, we have shown that MgCYP51 tightly bound agricultural azole fungicides (
16) such as epoxiconazole (
Kd, 17 nM), tebuconazole (
Kd, 27 nM), and triadimenol (
Kd, 30 nM), apart from prothioconazole, which bound weakly (
Kd, 14 μM) in an atypical fashion (not through direct coordination with the heme iron). The IC
50 determinations (
Fig. 7) using the MgCPR/MgCYP51 pairing and eburicol as the substrate demonstrated that prothioconazole was a very poor inhibitor. Prothioconazole is one of the most economically important fungicides currently used and was introduced in 2004. This study showed no significant inhibition of CYP51 activity by prothioconazole at concentrations up to 145 μM, corresponding to the atypical weak binding previously observed (
16). The desthio form of prothioconazole, however, was shown to be the most potent inhibitor of MgCYP51 (IC
50 of ∼0.6 μM), confirming that this is the active derivative of prothioconazole. This is corroborated by the findings of Parker et al. (
17) in studies with
C. albicans that the antifungal effect observed was due to prothioconazole being readily metabolized to its desthio form rather than the fungicide itself.
This study has shown the existence of a novel fungal CYP51 enzyme that is not only substrate specific but also temperature-sensitive in the presence of its native CPR. The homologous reconstitution system which has been developed in this study enables future in vitro studies on the effects of individual MgCYP51 point mutations, observed in M. graminicola field isolates, on both the azole antifungal resistance and catalytic efficiency. It will also allow the potential effects of new DMIs to be evaluated. Furthermore, this study has confirmed that the desthio form of prothioconazole is the active fungicide.