INTRODUCTION
Communities of sulfide-oxidizing microorganisms in marine sulfide-rich environments, such as wood falls, seeps, and stratified water columns, often harbor large communities of the epsilonproteobacterial genus
Arcobacter (
1–8). The
Arcobacter genus encompasses a diverse assemblage of species that include obligate and facultative chemolithoautotrophs as well as heterotrophs (see references
1,
9, and
10 and references therein). While much attention has focused on gut and food bearing pathogenic
Arcobacter species, the
Arcobacter genus also contains a wide variety of free-living, environmentally relevant species. For instance, the free-living species
Arcobacter butzleri, which has been identified to be an enteropathogen, has also been isolated from aquatic environments (e.g., lakes) (
11–14).
Arcobacter spp. have been enriched in engineered systems containing high levels of sulfide and high levels of organic matter (
9,
15–17), and
Arcobacter spp. have been found in association with unicellular protists, where the
Arcobacter spp. benefit from the transfer of labile organic matter and hydrogen (
18). The metabolic capability to utilize reduced and intermediate-oxidation-state sulfur compounds for respiration as an electron donor (
1,
11,
19) or even as an electron acceptor (
10) appears to contribute to the ability of several
Arcobacter spp. to thrive in marine, sulfur-rich (
6,
20,
21) environments.
Sulfur-rich environments can be found in coastal upwelling systems, such as those off the coasts of Peru and Namibia, where large fluxes of organic carbon deposition drive enhanced rates of microbial sulfate reduction and sulfide production within the underlying sediments (
22–25). During periods of sluggish water column circulation, dissolved hydrogen sulfide (H
2S and HS
−) diffuses out of the sediments and accumulates to concentrations often exceeding 20 μM in shelf bottom waters (
6,
25–29). These sulfidic events represent extreme manifestations of coastal deoxygenation processes and contribute to the formation of anoxic dead zones (
30–32). The occurrence of even low-micromolar concentrations of dissolved hydrogen sulfide restricts the availability of faunal habitat in hypoxic zones and eventually leads to a loss of faunal diversity and massive fish die-offs in otherwise productive, coastal upwelling systems (
31–34). Counteracting the accumulation of hydrogen sulfide is the rapid oxidation of dissolved sulfide at redoxclines mediated by a variety of bacteria that use dissolved oxygen or nitrate as the terminal electron acceptor (
6,
26,
27,
35,
36). The detection of abundant CO
2-fixing microbes in oxygen minimum zones (OMZs) and stratified basins, in concert with elevated rates of dark CO
2 fixation at sulfide-nitrate redoxclines, has led to the conclusion that chemolithoautotrophic bacteria are primarily responsible for the oxidation of sulfide (
6,
26–29,
35,
37,
38). In addition to oxidizing sulfide to less toxic elemental sulfur or sulfate, many sulfide-oxidizing bacteria contribute to fixed nitrogen loss by coupling dissolved sulfide oxidation to denitrification (
6,
26–28,
39,
40).
Arcobacter has been identified to be a potentially important sulfide-oxidizing, denitrifying bacterium in the sulfide-rich waters off the coast of Namibia (
6) and is hypothesized to serve a similar role in the sulfide-rich waters off the coast of Peru.
To further elucidate the role of Arcobacter associated with sulfidic events in marine ecosystems, we isolated a marine Arcobacter strain from a site in coastal, sulfidic Peruvian shelf waters, where Arcobacter spp. may comprise a substantial fraction of the bacterial community typically associated with sulfide oxidation. We analyzed the genome of the isolated Arcobacter and tested its physiology under conditions mimicking the Peru shelf environment from which it was isolated. In order to place the isolated Arcobacter in its environmental context, we examined the phylogenetic relationship of our isolated Arcobacter to the in situ populations of Arcobacter spp. and with respect to other sulfide-oxidizing chemolithotrophs. Lastly, we quantified the activity at the single-cell level of in situ populations of Arcobacter spp.
(This research was conducted by C. M. Callbeck in partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Ph.D. from the University of Bremen, 2017 [
41].)
DISCUSSION
The genotypic and physiologic characterizations of the isolated
Arcobacter PSE-93 strain demonstrate that we have isolated a new
Arcobacter species that we name
Arcobacter peruensis. Both the chemolithoheterotrophic genotype and the physiology of
A. peruensis suggest that it can thrive in the sulfide- and organic matter-rich environment in coastal Peru upwelling waters, where nitrate is supplied as an alternate electron acceptor. Our experiments employing environmentally relevant concentrations of substrates demonstrated that
A. peruensis grows best on a combination of hydrogen sulfide, nitrate, and acetate. It appears to be uniquely suited to an environment where nitrate or microaerophilic concentrations of dissolved oxygen are present and where the fluxes of small dissolved organic compounds (e.g., acetate) and sulfide are great enough to enhance growth. The obligate organotroph
A. peruensis thus differs from other environmentally relevant
Arcobacter species, which are either facultative heterotrophs and which can also grow autotrophically, such as
A. anaerophilus (
10), or which are strict autotrophs, such as
A. sulfidicus (
1). The lack of genes for autotrophic CO
2 fixation pathways and the presence of genes for organic carbon-dependent carboxylases in the genome indicate that the very low measured rates of CO
2 assimilation might be attributable to anaplerotic CO
2 uptake during organotrophy. In addition to being an obligate organotroph,
A. peruensis, unlike
A. anaerophilus and
A. nitrofigilis, has no nitrogen fixation genes and therefore lacks the ability to fix N
2 for growth.
In contrast to other
Arcobacter species that can reduce nitrate to ammonium (e.g.,
A. butzleri and
A. nitrofigilis) (
11,
50),
A. peruensis reduces nitrate to dinitrogen. The genes for a complete denitrification pathway are present in the genome of
A. peruensis (
Fig. 3), and the presence of this pathway was confirmed by the
15N labeling experiments. Complete denitrification by
A. peruensis contrasts with the denitrification ability of
A. anaerophilus, which is also capable of reducing nitrate to nitrite but lacks the
nir and
nrf genes and, thus, the ability to reduce nitrite and nitric oxide. On the other hand,
A. anaerophilus can use reduced sulfur species, such as tetrathionate and zerovalent sulfur (in the form of elemental sulfur or polysulfides), to oxidize organic compounds. Genomic analysis indicates that
A. peruensis does not appear to have the capacity to use intermediate-oxidation-state sulfur compounds as an electron acceptor. It is true that the
A. peruensis isolate can also grow heterotrophically on acetate in the absence of sulfide, but it does so only poorly, as the estimated doublings per day are 2-fold lower than those in the presence of dissolved sulfide (
Table 1). Our experiments suggest that
A. peruensis grows best by coupling dissimilatory nitrate reduction to dinitrogen with the oxidation of dissolved sulfide (
Fig. 4) and that environmental levels of sulfide, nitrate, and acetate could sustain the abundances of
Arcobacter cells observed
in situ (
Fig. 2b).
The low rates of CO
2 fixation determined by single-cell analysis of the
in situ Arcobacter population (
Fig. 6) are consistent with the conclusion that chemolithoheterotrophic
A. peruensis probably dominates the
in situ Arcobacter community. The rate of
Arcobacter CO
2-based growth, as measured by
in situ single-cell
13C uptake, would be far too low (doubling once per 100 days) to support the large cell densities of
Arcobacter observed
in situ, if it were an autotroph. We ascribe the low per cell rates of CO
2 fixation to anaplerotic reactions. In contrast,
UT. perditus (SUP05) and
Epsilonproteobacteria show active autotrophy
in situ (
27) (
Fig. 6) and contribute substantially (11% to 51%) to the rates of dark carbon fixation on the Peru shelf (see Table S2 in the supplemental material).
Acetate, a short-chain fatty acid produced during the degradation of organic matter via fermentation, could support
Arcobacter growth in the Peruvian OMZ waters. Permanently sulfidic marine basins exhibit not only elevated rates of dark carbon fixation but also high rates of both acetate production and acetate assimilation (0.05 to 0.5 μM day
−1) (
51). Acetate assimilation has been suggested to provide an important source of carbon for microbial growth on the highly productive northern Gulf of Mexico shelf (
52).
A. peruensis could assimilate acetate by converting it to acetyl-CoA using the combination of the high-affinity acetate permease (
Km = 5.4 μM) and the acetyl-CoA synthetase (
53,
54) (
Fig. 3). Acetyl-CoA is a key precursor molecule for various biosynthesis pathways (
55). Interestingly, the
Arcobacter strain isolated and described here was initially enriched on Peru OMZ shelf water without the addition of extra organic substrates, suggesting that
A. peruensis is very efficient at exploiting the residual dissolved organic pool in the Peru OMZ. The concentrations of dissolved organic matter in surface and benthic zone-influenced bottom waters of the shallow Peruvian OMZ shelf are high and in the range of 80 to 100 μmol liter
−1 (
56). Furthermore, other studies have indicated that
Arcobacter species may be capable of assimilating acetate under sulfidic conditions within sediments and at redoxclines (
3,
8).
Chemolithoheterotrophic growth may confer energetic advantages over a chemolithoautotrophic physiology in an organic matter-rich environment. For pyruvate, a key building block in biosynthesis, autotrophic CO
2 fixation requires between 0.6 and 2.3 mol ATP per mol of pyruvate formed, while acetate assimilation requires only 0.5 mol ATP per mol of pyruvate formed (
57). From the nanoSIMS-derived PSE-93 culture single-cell acetate assimilation rates (1.55 fmol C cell
−1 day
−1) obtained during experiments under sulfide-oxidizing, denitrifying conditions, we calculated an assimilation factor of 3.1 mol C per mol H
2S oxidized. This rate of acetate carbon assimilation exceeds the rates of CO
2 assimilation reported for cultivated chemolithoautotrophic sulfide-oxidizing bacteria, which range from 0.35 to 0.58 mol C assimilated per mol H
2S oxidized (
58–60). The lower energy constraints of
A. peruensis may enable
A. peruensis (and, presumably, other sulfide-oxidizing chemolithoheterotrophic bacteria) to outcompete sulfide-oxidizing chemolithoautotrophs (e.g., SUP05 bacteria) when the production or flux of small organic compounds is sufficient. Thus,
A. peruensis is most likely to bloom under highly sulfidic and organic matter-rich conditions, as observed in this study off the coast of Peru, and at other coastal, sulfidic environments, such as off the coast of Namibia (
6).
A chemolithoheterotrophic physiology is not without drawbacks. The requirement for labile organic matter, in addition to sulfide and nitrate, places
A. peruensis at a competitive disadvantage alongside chemolithoautotrophic bacteria that generate biomass (i.e., via CO
2 fixation) independently of organic matter availability. In addition, compared to other co-occurring sulfide-oxidizing bacteria (e.g., SUP05),
A. peruensis appears to lack the capacity to store intracellular sulfur. Genomic data showed the presence of the
soxCD genes, which is often correlated with a lack of intracellular sulfur storage in sulfide oxidizers (
46). NanoSIMS analysis of individual cells showed, moreover, that Peruvian OMZ
Arcobacter spp. were significantly lower in sulfur content (ANOVA, df = 2,
P < 0.001) than SUP05 and non-
Arcobacter Epsilonproteobacteria cells (
Fig. 4a and
b). In contrast, SUP05 bacteria, which co-occur with
Arcobacter in the sulfidic shelf waters, continue to denitrify using stored intracellular elemental sulfur and are, as a result of this ecophysiology, more broadly distributed within the Peru upwelling OMZ (
27). In contrast, the
Arcobacter dependency on sulfide and organic matter for growth ultimately constrains its distribution to sulfidic and highly productive shelf waters.
The metabolic flexibility inherent to the
Arcobacter genus has enabled
Arcobacter strains similar to
A. peruensis to gain a foothold in a marine redox transition zone that is often assumed to be dominated by chemolithoautotrophs (
6,
26,
28,
35,
37,
38). Despite its apparent restriction to sulfidic, eutrophic shelf systems, chemolithoheterotrophic metabolism, such as that exhibited by
A. peruensis, may play an important role in nitrogen and sulfur cycling in environments similar to those on the Peru shelf, especially as hypoxic, sulfidic coastal regions expand (
32). Organisms similar to the Peru upwelling
A. peruensis bacterium may be more widely spread, as indicated by the very close similarity of a Korean environmental strain (LPB0137). How much these and similar
Arcobacter species eventually contribute to sulfide oxidation and nitrogen loss through denitrification in increasingly eutrophic marine coastal ecosystems remains to be explored.
Description of Arcobacter peruensis sp. nov.
A. peruensis type strains: PSE-93, LMG 31510. Etymology: pe.ru.en′sis. N.L. masc. adj. peruensis, pertaining to Peru. Locality: isolated from coastal, sulfidic Peruvian shelf waters at 12.23°S, 77.18°W. Properties: Gram-negative, slightly elongated rods (0.9 μm in length and 0.6 μm in width). It grows chemolithoheterotrophically in sulfide-, nitrate-, and organic matter-rich environments in coastal upwelling water. It grows best by coupling dissimilatory nitrate reduction to dinitrogen to the oxidation of dissolved sulfide. Alternatively, heterotrophic growth on acetate in the absence of sulfide occurs, albeit at much slower doubling times. It grows aerobically on PY-BROTH medium (DSMZ, Germany) supplemented with 200 μM KH2PO4, 10 mM MgSO4·7H2O, 5 mM HEPES at a final pH of 7.8 and solidified with Bacto agar (1%, wt/vol). The median GC content of the type strain is 27.4 mol%.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are grateful to the Peruvian authorities for access to their national waters and to the captain and crew of RV Meteor Research Expedition M93.
C.M.C., G.L., R.A.S., and M.M.M.K. designed the study; C.M.C., C.P., B.V., H.S., S.L., P.F.H., and T.K. performed the experiments; C.M.C., C.P., G.L., B.V., T.G.F., B.M.F., P.F.H., S.L., T.K., and J.S.G. analyzed the data; C.M.C. and T.G.F. wrote the manuscript with substantial input from G.L., B.M.F., J.S.G., B.V., R.A.S., and M.M.M.K.
We thank G. Klockgether, D. Tienken, A. Schwedt, S. Haas, and K. Latham for analytical and laboratory assistance and C. Schelten for administrative support. A. Oren graciously assisted with the derivation of the species name
A. peruensis. We thank the Max Planck Genome Centre Cologne (
http://mpgc.mpipz.mpg.de/home/) for performing the genomic analysis in this study.
This work was supported by the Max Planck Society; the German National Science Foundation (DFG) Sonderforschungsbereich (SFB754) GEOMAR, Kiel, Germany; and a Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) scholarship to C.M.C. B.V. was supported by a European Research Council Starting Grant (640422).