INTRODUCTION
JC virus (JCV) belongs to the genus
Polyomavirus (PyV) of the
Polyomaviridae family and infects about two-thirds of the adult population worldwide without obvious clinical symptoms (
9,
26). Although the route of transmission is not resolved, mucosal surfaces in the oropharyngeal, respiratory, or gastrointestinal tract have been discussed as entry sites. During postulated primary viremia, many tissues might be exposed, but JCV persists in the renourinary tract, with intermittent periods of asymptomatic shedding into urine (
6,
15). The key disease caused by JCV is PyV-associated progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) (
34,
42) and less frequently PyV-associated nephropathy (
13). PML may arise in a wide range of patients who are characterized by a profound cellular immunodeficiency (
24,
27), but the highest rates of 1 to 8% have been reported for HIV/AIDS patients before the availability of combination antiretroviral therapy (cART) (
1,
3,
8,
23). Recently, PML was described as a complication in patients successfully treated for multiple sclerosis or of inflammation patients treated with the monoclonal antibody natalizumab, an anti-α4 integrin which effectively prevents homing to the sites of inflammation in the brain or the gastrointestinal tract (
25,
28).
The therapeutic options for PML are rather limited at the moment and seem to depend on the underlying type of immunodeficiency and the ability to recover JCV-specific immune functions. At present, no antiviral therapy of proven efficacy is available to treat JCV replication in PML. The mainstay of current therapy is to allow specific immunity to regain control over JCV replication (
14,
24). However, this approach is not uniformly successful, even in HIV/AIDS patients treated with cART (
23). An antiviral drug with efficacy against JCV replication in the central nervous system (CNS) might halt the progression and extend the time window for immunological recovery. Cidofovir (CDV), an acyclic nucleotide phosphonate analogue of deoxycytosine monophosphate, has been a promising drug because of its inhibitory activity for nonhuman PyVs
in vitro (
2) but showed some toxicity in cells of neural origin (
21). Initial studies suggested that CDV might be an effective treatment of PML (
11,
16), but most current studies to date have failed to demonstrate a benefit of CDV (
10,
31,
41).
More recently, CMX001, the hexadecyloxypropyl lipid conjugate of CDV, was found to inhibit polyomavirus BK (BKV) replication in primary human proximal tubular epithelial cells at a 90% effective concentration (EC
90) of 0.31 μM at 3 days postinfection (dpi), with a more immediate and lasting effect than CDV (
4,
38). Similarly, reduced intracellular viral loads were seen in the human embryonic lung fibroblast cell line WI-38 at 7 dpi at an EC
50 of 0.13 μM, 800-fold-lower than the 115.1 μM observed for CDV (
37). For JCV replication, only recent
in vitro data on CMX001 became available while the current work was in progress: in SVG cells, a glia-derived cell line frequently used to propagate JCV
in vitro due to the favorable effect of the constitutively expressed large T antigen (LTag) of the simian polyomavirus SV40 (
30), CMX001 at 0.1 μM decreased the JCV infection by 60%, with an estimated EC
50 of 0.045 μM (
22). Here, we report the effects of CMX001 on JCV replication in human fetal brain progenitor-derived astrocytes (
17,
33) and compare the results to JCV replication in COS-7 cells bearing the same SV40 LTag-expressing vector as SVG cells.
DISCUSSION
Antivirals for treatment of JCV-mediated PML are lacking, and the difficulty of perpetuating this virus in relevant in vitro cell culture has hampered a better characterization of potential candidate drugs. Our data demonstrate that CMX001 inhibits JCV replication in human fetal brain progenitor-derived astrocytes (PDA) and in COS-7 cells. CMX001 reduced not only the progeny viral loads in the cell culture supernatants but also the number of JCV LTag- and VP1-expressing cells, as well as the number of infectious progeny virus when supernatants were titrated on COS-7 as indicator cells.
In PDA cells, the CMX001 EC
50 was as low as 5.55 nM and the EC
90 as low as 19.7 nM (
Fig. 5A). When attempting to characterize side effects of CMX001, we noted that crude viability visualized by phase contrast or by dye exclusion was little affected. However, similar to our studies on CMX001 and CDV inhibition of BKV replication in primary tubular epithelial cells (
4,
38), the overall metabolic activity of PDA cells in the WST-1 assay was little affected up to CMX001 concentrations of 0.6 μM, where a reduction to 70% of the activity of untreated PDA was noted. Using estimates in this range would increase the corresponding selectivity index (SI
50) to more than 100. However, given the presumed key mechanism of CMX001 as a cytosine phosphonate analogue, dye exclusion and WST-1 might underestimate toxic effects on the host cells. Using BrdU incorporation, we noted a more-pronounced inhibitory effect of CMX001, yielding a CC
50 of 184.6 nM and a CC
90 of 5054 nM, with a corresponding SI
50 and SI
90 of 33.3 and 256.1, respectively. Although these estimates appeared more conservative, they still provide good support for bringing CMX001 to clinical trials. Single doses of 2 mg/kg of body weight were well tolerated in a phase 1 clinical study conducted with healthy volunteers, producing peak concentrations in excess of 0.6 μM per week without significant side effects (
39).
Our results in COS-7 cells support the inhibitory activity of CMX001 on JCV replication in a cell line known to significantly facilitate JCV replication by activating JCV early gene expression through constitutively expressed SV40 LTag (
17). Compared to PDA cells, COS-7 cells required 19- and 37-fold-higher CMX001 concentrations for a JCV EC
50 and EC
90 of 0.1 μM and 0.74 μM, respectively (
Fig. 5B). BrdU incorporation was more affected than the metabolic WST-1 activity, yielding a CMX001 CC
50 of 0.67 μM (SI
50, 6.7) and a CC
90 of 12.2 μM (SI
90, 16.5), respectively.
The difference between PDA and COS-7 cells with a lower EC
50 and EC
90 and a higher SI
50 and SI
90 suggests an enhanced effectiveness of CMX001 in primary human target cells. This may result from the cell type (primary human brain-derived astrocytes versus monkey kidney-derived cell line). Progeny virus in untreated PDA increased by approximately 2 log
10 geq/ml at 7 dpi compared to a more than 3-log
10 geq/ml rise of that in COS-7 cells at 5 dpi (
Fig. 1), indicating that the JCV replication cycle is significantly accelerated in COS-7 cells compared to that in PDA cells. Our earlier data indicate that this difference in JCV replication can be attributed in part to the
trans-activating effect of SV40 LTag in COS-7 cells in comparison to results in CV-1 precursor cells (
17). Recently, CMX001 at a 0.1 μM concentration was reported to reduce the number of JCV-positive cells by 60% (estimated EC
50 of 0.045 μM) in SVG cells, a human glia-derived cell line also expressing SV40 LTag (
22). Although no data were reported for the CMX001 CC
50 (SI
50) or the EC
90 (CC
90, SI
90) values of JCV replication in SVG cells, thus precluding a more detailed comparison, the EC
50 for JCV in SVG cells were close to our results in COS-7 cells, suggesting a key role for LTag expression.
The role of LTag expression and CMX001 susceptibility is of interest since it may pertain to the prophylactic use of CMX001 preventing
de novo cell infection and to its use in patients with established PML and ongoing high-level replication of JCV variants with a rearranged noncoding control region (NCCR) and correspondingly increased cellular levels of LTag expression (
17,
29). For BKV replication in primary human renal tubular epithelial cells, the CMX001 EC
90 was determined to be 310 nM (
38), and the EC
50 estimates were approximately 0.04 μM (H. H. Hirsch, unpublished data) using a BKV strain (Dunlop) adapted to tissue culture bearing a highly rearranged NCCR with significantly increased viral early gene expression (
18,
38). Similarly, higher CMX001 EC
50s have been reported by Randhawa et al. using rearranged BKV strains in a human lung fibroblast cell line, WI-98 (
37). The JCV Mad-4 strain was isolated from the brain of a PML patient and is considered representative of other PML isolates (
12,
32). In fact, rearranged NCCRs are a hallmark of practically all JCV variants identified in patients with PML today. We have recently demonstrated that compared to the archetype JCV NCCR, these naturally occurring rearranged JCV NCCRs show an increased viral early gene expression and a viral replication rate similar to that of the Mad-4 isolate (
17). Therefore, we consider Mad-4 an acceptable model strain for measuring antiviral activities for the clinically relevant pathology of PML and expect equal or higher potency of CMX001 against slowly replicating JCV isolates with archetype NCCRs.
Upon uptake into the cell, the lipid phosphate ester linkage of CMX001 is cleaved by cellular phospholipases to release CDV that is converted to CDV diphosphate (CDV-pp) by cellular kinases (
20). CDV-pp is a potent inhibitor of DNA synthesis catalyzed by herpesvirus and adenovirus DNA polymerases (
19,
40). However, polyomaviruses do not encode a viral DNA polymerase. Therefore, the sensitivity of JCV replication in PDA might be related to a more favorable uptake of CMX001, with subsequent enhanced conversion of CDV to active CDV-pp in
de novo infected and LTag-expressing cells. In COS-7 or SVG cells chronically expressing LTag, any of these steps could be altered, including the membrane lipid composition, the phospholipase localization and activity, and the intracellular nucleotide pools, which are possibly more rapidly turned over and replenished, together leading to a less-active drug and less inhibition.
Antiviral agents, and in particular CDV, have been used to treat PML patients but with little success (
10,
31,
41). Two recent studies of JCV in SVG cells indicated that CDV may not be very effective (
5,
22). Instead, our study supports and extend the results of Jiang et al. (
22) and provide the most complete data on the inhibitory characteristics of CMX001 on JCV replication in primary human glia-derived astrocytes with regard to the effective concentrations, cytotoxic concentrations, and selectivity indices. The data indicate that CMX001 has a favorable inhibitory and toxicity profile in this relevant
in vitro model of JCV replication. While data for humans are currently being collected, studies using [
14C]CMX001 in mice reported potent inhibition of experimental herpes simplex virus encephalitis, reaching drug concentrations of 0.01 to 0.02 mg equivalents per gram of spinal cord and brain (
36). Together with the oral bioavailability and the lack of nephrotoxicity from CMX001 observed to date in preclinical and clinical studies (
20,
35), our results provide an important rational basis for further exploring the antiviral potential of CMX001 in clinical studies of JCV-mediated PML.